Keith’s 10 March note: Last night @NASA and other main NASA Twitter accounts devoted a lot of real time tweeting and linking of images and references in support of the premiere of “Cosmos”. Most notably, President Obama thought it worth his time to make a rather unprecedented on-air introduction to the series. Oddly, NASA’s Astrobiology program did not say one damn thing. There is no mention on NASA’s main astrobiology website. No mention was made on their 880,000 follower AstrobiologyNAI Twitter account either.
Keith’s 16 March update: Tonight’s episode was devoted to Astrobiology. At one point Neil Tyson notes “All of the astrobiologists since Carl Sagan have wondered whether life swims in Titan’s oceans”. Astrobiology is getting a free PR boost at zero expense to NASA. All NASA has to do is pay attention, tell others about how it relates to what their tax dollars are doing, and benefit from the exposure. Yet NASA’s Astrobiology Institute has maintained a total black out on “Cosmos”.
If NASA can seize the opportunity to use social media to embrace and enhance Oscar buzz about “Gravity”, ISS visibility in “Live From Space” – and the Cosmos premiere last week, then why can’t NASA SMD and NAI do so with Cosmos over the coming weeks? Last week I was convinced that NAI staff was clueless in this regard. Now I am convinced that they are just incompetent – and negligent. And why doesn’t NASA HQ care – or have the ability/interest to direct NAI to show the same enthusiasm that the rest of the agency has aptly demonstrated?

 
Of all the disciplines at NASA, this new Cosmos series probably highlights the core themes of Astrobiology more than almost any other. Its like a free weekly advertisement for the whole concept of what Astrobiology has come to mean over the 15 years.  Indeed, I doubt Astrobiology would even exist were it not for the cross disciplinary seeds sewn by the original Cosmos series and efforts by Carl Sagan to link life and the universe into one cohesive framework – something Neil Tyson continues to do. Baffling. Someone at NASA needs to kick the NASA Astrobiology Institute in their collective ass and get them to start paying attention to what millions of people are learning about their program.
Check Astrobiology News for more information on this topic.

Biologist, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA Space Biologist and Payload integrator, Editor of NASAWatch.com and Astrobiology.com, Lapsed climber, Explorer, Synaesthete, Former Challenger Center board member 🖖🏻

11 replies on “Why Is NASA's Astrobiology Program STILL Ignoring "Cosmos"?”

  1. The NASA Astrobiology Institute twitter account hasn’t tweeted anything since late January, so their lack of tweeting about Cosmos shouldn’t be seen as a surprise and probably has nothing to do with their interest, or lack thereof, in the show.

    1. Actually the NASA Astrobiology Institute has chronic problems with regard to PR, social media, and cooperating with the rest of NASA – as very senior sources across the agency readily – and repeatedly – admit to me.

  2. If anyone would like an astrobiology perspective (but certainly not THE astrobiology perspective) on this, I’ve been tweeting about the show (@shawndgoldman) – at times from an astrobiological perspective – and recording my thoughts at http://paleblueblog.org.

    I don’t have any advance notice of what the content is, so all the posts are off-the-cuff (and, naturally, < 140 characters). And, just like the rest of you, I spend a lot of time in total awe of the amazing graphics package. But I have some insights into the research that’s the foundation of the series, and I try to bring in the thoughts of other planetary scientists and astrobiologists when I catch their tweets.

    1. Thanks for making this effort. It is totally baffling to see NASA.gov ignoring Cosmos – especially when it is dripping with Astrobiology goodness.

      1. As to the Astrobiology Program and the NAI, I think you have a point that this is an opportunity to be leveraged.

        However, it’s not such an obvious choice for a research program to do this. Tweeting is free, but tweeting effectively is far from it. To really do it right you want to have a team, ala the Curiosity Rover twitter team, with scientists, public engagement experts, and social media experts. That ain’t cheap, and it would siphon money away from grants for research. And it’s not like you can just “rent” an effective social media team for events like this.

        Further, although astrobiology is the backbone of the material covered on Cosmos, there’s lots of planetary science, Earth science, heliophysics, and astrophysics presented as well. To that end, it shows how astrobiology provides a nice theme for the scientific endeavors of the agency, but the science presented transcends astrobiology. So maybe SMD should be doing this, with input from all the divisions (including a lot of material from AB)?

        Honestly, I don’t have the answer here. But that’s why I don’t think it’s an easy call, especially when research funding is tight. (Should *every* large research program at NASA have a social media team?) It’s also why I was really happy to see the accounts with an existing standing team (@NASA, @NASAGoddard, @NASA_EO, etc) tweeting. To me, that makes a LOT more sense than standing up a team just for this opportunity.

        (Full disclosure: I’m a CS at GSFC, and my last postdoc was in the Astrobiology Program at HQ. So I have a bias towards trusting these folks, who I know value outreach and whom I have personally seen make good decisions in a budget-limited environment. Also, the thoughts above are all my own, not representative of any of them.)

        1. I was a participant in all of the initial workshops that first defined Astrobiology for NASA in 1997-1998. That is when I bought astrobiology.com – so … I have been watching this for a long time. I know the players all too well – hence my annoyance and frustration with their inability to take Astrobiology where it can and should go. If not them, then who? If not now, when?

          1. Well – and now I’m *REALLY* exhibiting my biases – I think one thing the NAI has done particularly well is develop astrobiology as an area of focused research, and an associated professional community to pursue it.

            As a result of those efforts, we have a generation of astrobiologists (including yours truly) with degrees or certificates in the field and multi-discipline research networks tailored to the search for life beyond Earth. They’re now working alongside senior scientists whose research has significantly advanced our understanding of the possibilities for life and the interactions of our biosphere with the rest of the planet. Developing that science community had to come first, and I think the NAI was successful in that endeavor.

            So how should we leverage this to take astrobiology to the next level? It’s a great question, but it’s also a great time to be asking it. With the re-organization of PSD’s R&A program (an opportunity for expanding the astrobiology community), a new head of the NAI, and new NAI teams about to be selected, there’s lots of change afoot. But with that change comes opportunity.

  3. “Last week I was convinced that NAI staff was clueless in this regard.
    Now I am convinced that they are just incompetent – and negligent.” God Keith you keep me in stitches. I asked a couple of NASA civil servants last Tuesday about the show. I got blank stare. Oh well.

    1. That’s ’cause they don’t actually have to engage any part of their brain to get paid. Sorry, it’s not meant as a general statement but it does appear that many civil (we call them public) servants aren’t capable of, or even remotely interested in doing any constructive activity whatsoever.
      End of rant 🙂

  4. Keith:

    Could it be, possibly, the mention of persecution by the Church way back when in the first episode and the insistence that evolution trumps creationism hands down in the second? Just sayin’…

    Come to think of it, under those circumstances, it’s amazing that Fox is carrying Cosmos in the first place. Won’t stuff like that offend ‘their base’?

    tinker

Comments are closed.