NASA missions bid for extensions, Nature
“… like six other ongoing NASA missions studying the Moon, Mars and Saturn, Opportunity’s money is due to run out at the end of the US fiscal year, on 30 September. Managers for each mission are trying to convince the agency to cough up continued funding, and their arguments are due on 11 April. A ‘senior review’ panel of external planetary scientists will rank the proposals’ potential science return, and submit their suggestions to NASA headquarters for a final decision.”
Viable Missions May Face The Budget Axe
Comments are closed.

This is simply sad. Our military spends $150 million (2009 dollars) on a single, YF-22 Raptor, and NASA is fighting to keep alive at least 7 programs on or around other worlds. I don’t get it: death machine vs. discovery machine. And I am even a pilot (love planes), but what is wrong with our species? Maybe we do deserve to go extinct.
Just saw your cost list. Not much compared to other programs. But how cheap could some one do it for to keep from turning the lights out on the spacecrafts?
This breakout was given in the original article, so I cant talk to the numbers. The problem is with how our government manages its business.
One Example: When a project has not used all of its allocated funds in a given year, it is punished by not getting the same level of funding next year as opposed to rewarded for being frugal and efficient. Then, if the project happened to ask for the same budget again, it would have a surplus to actually do novel or additional work in the new year (assuming the same level of efficiency is kept).
Are not these vehicles already in space and working? Why not turn their operation over to the private sector? Perhaps to universities. How much fat is there in these programs and how could they be operated on the cheap so that future data could be archived. Or is this a case of only NASA can operate spacecraft because space is so hard and expensive???
Find a way to keep them alive PLEASE!
Get creative!
Save the data!
Your second question is great!!!! Ive been saying this for years. What needs to change is that the Government needs to make it a “requirement” for every exploration mission/craft have in their proposal, a means of seamlessly handing the whole mission (control, operations, ect.) over to an institution of higher education (many different awarding paths) at the point that the Government chooses to stop funding its operation. We would probably still have Viking 1 and 2 still working if this was the case. But who is in a position and really cares to make this a law???
Would congressional porkonauts be willing to pass this pork off? specially if it is going to be handed off to a university from another state?
Most probes are operated by JPL, which in turn IS operated by a university, CalTech. While I agree that NASA is hardly the world leader in cost savings, universities nowadays can also spend money like it’s going out of style.
Where do you expect universities to get money to run these programs? Have you seen the trend in university funding? Or do you actually think that the government will be more inclined to pay money for a program that the wanted to shutter?
If you want people to get creative, you have to find the source of the money that will be needed.
For a bit of perspective, consider that research money at universities is generally getting more difficult to come by. I’ve personally seen the result of the decreased flux of research money.
Mr. Squared
How much does it really cost to operate each one of these space crafts?? What are the costs. How many people are NEEDED to drive them. Why does one spacecraft cost so much more than another once it is in space?? Shouldn’t they cost about the same?? Where does this money go?? We don’t wire money to the spacecraft. How much is salaries? How much is overhead heating buildings and such. I would guess that to just keep the ship alive and collect the data could be done for well under a million per year per program.
If so who mirght be interested in helping collect the data might Spaced be interested Mars data? How about Bigelow don’t they follow their satellites now??? If the cost to keep the data coming can be done cheap enough there should be all kinds of possibilities???
Any one out there in the know??
What about these contracts?? What happens once gov funding ends???
don’t many of these craft provide info of value over time weather and such??
Little help here please!!!
Again, where is the money supposed to come from?
Universities don’t put money on the table, they take money off the table. In return they provide the labor of graduate students and researchers. Generally basic science is funded only by NSF, NASA, other government agencies, and occasionally private foundations and donors.
Well they could try some real cost control on their major missions for a start. Modify the contracts to performance milestone fixed payments rather than cost-plus. How would that go for innovative? I know, not possible since the contracts have already been signed, sigh!
There are new contracts coming along. Also even a cost plus contract can be performance milestoned – NASA simply does not pay until the milestone has been completed.
Andrew.
Is that the case for SLS and MPCV?
Yes a cost-plus contract can be performance milestoned however what invariably happens with cost-plus is that beancounters (and I speak from personal experience here) utilise all possible methods for variation claims and those personnel are far more skilled and specialised in claiming that most government organisations are at refuting and so they often simply pay up.
If we need an example just look at the mess that the EELV contracts are in. The government can’t even get a decent handle on the real costs of the program and ULA just keeps moving the goalposts on them. Poor blighters – that’s the gov’t sods that have to try to administer the contracts.
Just saying.
Oh and agree with your comment re: cutting big programs below.
Cheers,
Neil
One advantage of milestones is that the outfeed is defined in advance, this reduced the wiggle room.
I have not seen the SLS and MPCV contracts so I cannot do a detailed comment on their content.
It is easier to save 5% by cutting back the big programmes than eliminating lots of smaller programmes.
Said like a true Tea Party member! 🙂
That attitude will not save them.
Well, the James Webb Space Selescope has discovered a black hole before it even launches. It’s the near-Earth object that sucks away all of NASA’s money…