Rep. Suhas Subramanyam (VA-10) at the NASA HQ Rally
Rep. Suhas Subramanyam (VA-10) at the NASA HQ Rally

Marc’s note: It’s election season north of the border with Canada heading to the polls to elect a new federal government on Monday, October 19th. Rarely does space enter the election picture. This year is different. In the last week one news story with national reach and an editorial have put space on the election map.
The Canadian Space Commerce Association, of which I’m the Executive Director, issued a press release two days after the election was called calling on all federal parties to commit to a long-term space plan to be completed by the end of 2016 with input from all stakeholders. The three main parties who have a chance to form the next government were contacted along with the media. The Canadian Press (Canada’s equivalent to the AP) picked up on the story.
The good news is that the Liberals and New Democratic Party (NDP) have both committed to a long-term space plan. The ruling Conservatives had no comment. Here’s the first story.
Liberals and NDP promise long-term space plan if elected, Canadian Press
The other news item is an editorial which appeared in yesterday’s Ottawa Citizen from David Emerson who led a government mandated independent national review of the aerospace sector in 2012. Emerson is highly respected and a former government Cabinet Minister.
Emerson: Let’s reclaim our status as a leading spacefaring nation
“The next, most critical stage will be a concrete plan for long-term investments in space infrastructure. Such a plan would include commitments to space investment priorities reflecting the needs of Canada, the operational objectives of government departments and agencies, and Canada’s industrial capabilities.”
The election result will determine which direction Canada heads. If the current Conservative government is re-elected the current course will be maintained which may not be a positive sign. If either of the opposition parties win, then positive change should happen.

Marc Boucher is an entrepreneur, writer, editor, podcaster and publisher who has worked in space media for more than 25 years. In 1999 he co-founded SpaceRef with Keith Cowing. The new media company grew into a network that included NASA Watch and The Astrobiology Web. After selling SpaceRef, he joined Multiverse Media, which later merged with SpaceNews. There he helped steer the combined company toward more multimedia, a subscription paywall and intelligence products, and pushed for a mobile app. He is also the founder of SpaceQ Media, Canada’s space news and market intelligence publication.

Marc started his first Internet content business in 1992 and hasn’t looked back. When he’s not working, he loves exploring Canada and the world and expanding his photography skills.

7 replies on “Is Positive Change Coming to Canada's Space Program?”

  1. Marc,

    I, like you, have been following Canadian space policy debates for a while and I’m not optimistic that anything gets to be very different, no matter who forms the government. My observation is that these debates are locked in a do-nothing cycle, where a new minister or new space initiative forms a new policy committee or new council filled with luminaries which end up spending 18-24 months to come back with a list of recommendations not much different from what is already been happening for years – some mix of R&D, geospatial infrastructure, some astronaut time, some robotics work and a smattering of work on life sciences and planetary missions. Nothing much different from year to year no matter who sits on these committees and what they talk about.

    The real issue is there is a lack of real conviction on the political level of what they want Canada to really accomplish in space that is unique. Nor does there seem to be any will to change the structure of the country’s current sleepy space infrastructure. I don’t see this in any party, and I don’t see real evidence that even if there is a new government that they will do anything different than another cycle of what I described above.

    If the Canadian government, at the highest levels, starts talking seriously about this outside of siloed editorials and starts having conviction about one thing in particular – like supporting asteroid mining, or developing LEO platforms – and starts moving the country’s infrastructure out of middle-of-nowhere places like St-Hubert (where the CSA currently is), then I will take this seriously. Otherwise, I expect the real space developments to happen elsewhere.

    Ian

    1. I’m not Canadian, but that sounds about right to me.

      Doing a bit of spadework on Emerson, it seems he may be Canada’s rough equivalent of Sen. Richard Shelby (R-Alabama). Emerson used to be a Liberal, but switched to Conservative after they took control of the Canadian government and then was ousted anyway by his constituents. Shelby used to be a Democrat but switched parties after the 1994 Republican wave election put Democrats in the minority in both houses of Congress. Pity his resume departs from that of Emerson in that Shelby has managed to stay in office since flipping.

      Both Emerson and Shelby seem to have preserved their essentially statist, corporatist views of things despite their nominal new allegiances. Both seem mostly interested in boosting the amount of government spending they would get to ladle out to favored firms.

      Canada, like the U.S. would be better off de-emphasizing centrally-planned government space initiatives in favor of supporting entrepreneurial space firms with innovative ideas – mainly by not hobbling them with a lot of regulation and taxation.

      Mr. Housley is also right on the money. Canada could get a lot more bang for their space buck by going either the sole-tenant or time-share routes on a Bigelow LEO hab. Once U.S. Commercial Crew platforms are operational, the Canadian astronaut corps could get a lot more on-orbit time a lot faster than they have done or will do via minority participation in ISS. Both legacy (MDA, et al) and startup firms in Canada could get a lot more experimental space and time at much better rates than ISS currently affords them. Why not put multiple Canadarms on a LEO Bigelow hab and name it Kraken?

  2. You Probably shouldn’t try to compete in the orbital launch arena until the price point settles down. Instead, bank on that price point dropping further.
    Call Bigalow. In less than 5 years Canada could have its own orbiting research facility. How much would it cost, if done that way? Probably surprising amounts of not very much. It would put Canada on the map with the U.S., Russia and China as having launched its own space station, and be the first independent inflatable module launched by a national space agency…the start of what will be a great big trend. Canada is an ISS and NASA partner, so they could pick the brains of that knowledgebase the whole way.

    1. With Canada’s robotic arm experience, robotic refuelling tugs, depots, etc, might be a better tech to chase.

      1. Of course, for starters. But my point is that Canada…nor anyone else…will have to keep their feet on the ground. The cost of access will drop so low that keeping all your research amd researchers on the ground will be silly.
        Everyone, you, me, non-profits, small business, large business, government agencies that focus on more grounded things…like NOAA…we all need to take a second look at what we do and ask ourselves how cheap, routine access to LEO would be useful for us and make our future plans accordingly. Look at the billionaires from the PC and Internet revolutions. They thought of new ideas that leverage a new world born of new tech.

      2. How much is too much for Canada to pay for a space station? 10 million? 50 million? It won’t need to be inhabited full time, Skylab, Mir, and (whatever the Chinese call theirs) weren’t. What useful research can Canada do on their own space station? The ISS is about to become obsolete, not only because the tech will pass it up, but also because it’ll no longer be such a big deal that it needs some huge, multi-nation effort that costs a gazilion dollars. Everyone will go off on their own, and not just nations either. If NOAA has a budget for their own weather satellites launched by ULA, does Canada have the budget for a small Bigelow inflatable space station launched on the Falcon 9?

  3. Hello. The article says the emerson guy is a respected figure.
    Unfortunately..what I read that he wrote makes me..totally gag.
    Has anyone ever met a used car salesman?

Comments are closed.