Sen. Hutchison challenges NASA spending on commercial spacecraft, Houston Chronicle
“I’m frankly floored as you know from our conversation that it would be so blatant to take it right out of Orion and (the space launch system) and put it into commercial crew rather than trying to accomplish the joint goals that we have of putting forward both and making sure that we didn’t take away from the timetables for the future to shore up commercial crew,” Hutchison told Bolden.
NASA chief defends 2013 budget in Congress, space.com via MSNBC
“I don’t doubt your sincerity in shared goals, but what I’m very concerned about is the implementation that is reflected in the numbers of the budget that the president released,” Hutchison said.”
NASA may need to use Russian flights longer, Wall Street Journal via Fox
“NASA is drafting backup plans to prolong the use of Russian spacecraft for ferrying astronauts to the International Space Station, even as agency officials play down those options and express hope that private rockets and capsules will be available for such trips within five years.”‘
Russia Space Agency chief Popovkin hospitalised
“Head of the Russian Federal Space Agency (Roskosmos) Vladimir Popovkin has been taken to the Burdenko Hospital in connection with his health deterioration, the agency’s press service told Itar-Tass.”

Biologist, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA Space Biologist and Payload integrator, Editor of NASAWatch.com and Astrobiology.com, Lapsed climber, Explorer, Synaesthete, Former Challenger Center board member 🖖🏻

35 replies on “Breaking The Soyuz Habit Is Hard To Do”

  1. I dont know which is worse…further dependence on Russians to get us to ISS and back , or depending on Kay Baily Hutchison for leadership. Torturous either way . How did we get here ?  GCB ain;t got nuthin’ on that lady…

  2. Black is White and White is Black when it comes to Commercial Crew.

    You have Republicans acting like Democrats, and Democrats acting like Republicans.

    From my piece over at TMC Commercial Spacecraft Companies Ante Up on Capitol Hill

    ““It is important to note, in this [fiscal] environment, we want to think
    about the appropriate role of government,” Fattah (D-PA) said. “Here is an
    activity where there’s really no reason for the government to compete
    with the private sector…We should be supporting the private sector…”

    Meanwhile, the Texas Republicans want 1) Less competition 2) More government regulation 3) More government control.

    1.  What do Soyuz, Orion and SLS have in common? They are products of an arsenal system.

      Commercial Crew  (with the exception of CST-100) isn’t a product of an arsenal system.

    2. Actually Doug, this is simply a case of following the money.  Texas senators and representatives are trying to save Johnson. Fattah is a representative from Philadelphia and his district is only a few miles from the National Aerospace Training and Research Center, a private facility that offers astronaut training. If commercial space flight takes off (I guess pun intended), then where are the workers going to get trained?

      1. Fattah has Boeing in his district, I believe.

        Screwing Commercial crew to save Johnson has no logic. And JSC doesn’t make campaign contributions.

        1. JSC does not make campaign contributions, but it is a source of government funding and jobs going to that part of Texas.  Commercial space would most likely divert a good portion of that elesewhere (at least in a sane world).  Also, please correct me if I am wrong, as I probably am, but doesn’t the Boeing plant in Philadelphia concentrate on military aircraft (helicopters in particular)?

          To add more conspiracy theories, from what state was the last president (who seems to have been reviled by a lot of democrats)?

          My point being that the behavior of most politicians can usually be traced to reasons that are not always stated.  Again, though, I am cynical.

          And in other news, water is wet.

          1.  Commercial space would most likely divert a good portion of that elesewhere (at least in a sane world).
            Government developed space is built by “commercial” companies. I know that after a while, JSC/MSFC think of these primes as extensions of NASA (this is a source of the problem), but they are not.

            Flying any astros on anything, even a nuclear powered pogo stick, would mean more for JSC to do – e.g. JSC is supposed to be about what you are DOING in space too!

            I think anything different, even success … would cause them to fear loss.

  3. NASA’s new manned spaceflight focus is supposed to be on beyond LEO missions. So Hutchison and Nelson should be concerned when money is being shifted from that program– even if its only about $250 million in reduction. But, if anything, SLS/MPCV funding should be increased to insure that the system is fully operational by 2020.

    The real question to ask is why ISS cost are so highly inflated under this administration. When Obama came to office, NASA estimates for the cost of the ISS program after the end of the Shuttle program were supposed to rise from $2 billion a year to as high as $2.65 billion a year. Now, under the Obama administration, ISS cost will range from at least $3 billion a year to over $3.2 billion a year (nearly $600 million a year  more in NASA spending on the ISS).

    NASA estimates in 2009 for beyond LEO spending after shuttle retirement was to increase from $3.4 billion a year to as high as $5.6 billion a year. But under this administration, manned spaceflight beyond LEO spending actually declines from $3.4 billion when Obama first came to office and is estimated not to rise above $3 billion a year. That’s a $2.6 billion a year difference between what NASA originally intended to spend money on after then end of the $3 billion a year shuttle program.

    So LEO spending under this administration continues to increase while beyond LEO spending continues to decline!

    Marcel F. Williams

    1.  Not sure but the difference happens to be about the cost that we are paying the Russians for crew transport.  Is crew transport now under the ISS budget line?  It was probably under the Shuttle budget line in the past. 

    2. It’s a rare NASA estimate that does not either rise with time, or underestimate actual costs when the bill arrives.

      1.  Exactly, which makes the more than $400 million a year reduction in spending on NASA’s beyond LEO launch system and spacecraft and the  over $2.6 billion reduction a year originally projected for such vehicles after the Space Shuttle ending rather interesting:-) And it also explains why the administration says that the first manned launches of NASA’s new beyond LEO system will not occur until nearly 4 years after the first test launch.

        Its pretty obvious that they are purposely underfunding NASA’s beyond LEO program while inflating the cost of the LEO programs.

        Marcel F. Williams

        1.  I’m not sure you can fund SLS/Orion well. Even if you use every last dollar of NASA for it.

          The reason costs mount following Shuttle conclusion is well known – the Shuttle components cost factors start rising, because a) no use and b) no funding to maintain skills because of no use. This was expected.

          And will accelerate.

          The other issue many don’t get, is that this stuff has its origins in the 70’s. To re-evolve it for SLS use means to reinvent it. You have no idea how expensive that is going to be.

          This was why the three engine, 70t version (or so called Jupiter 130) was the only game to play. And, the smart thing to do was to get it up while Shuttle was still flying pre STS135. Duh.

    3. “NASA’s new manned spaceflight focus is supposed to be on beyond LEO missions.”

      According to who? Not the the President. Not to Bolden or Garver, except to the degree they have been forced by Congress.

      As the president has said, unless we can regain a share of high-tech manufacturing we will not even be able to maintain our standard of living. The US lead in commercial aerospace and other high-tech manufacturing is being steadily eliminated by competitors in countres with more effective industrial policies. MPCV/Orion has no commercial benefits and doesn’t even have the interest of foriegn partners. 

      Resaerch and technology (the small part of NASA that actually tries to develop things that are useful here on earth) has been slashed.

      And the only part of manned spaceflight that might possibly generate a profit, tourism, is basically on indefinite hold because of the lack of any affordable access to space.

      1.  MPCV/Orion has no commercial benefits and doesn’t even have the interest of foriegn partners.
        The suggestion of a service module from the ATV for Orion was an attempt to see if a joint ESA/NASA move for HSF craft might be possible – none of the players are fond of the idea, as they unsurprisingly all want their own “all up”, even if none of them can have any of it.

        Part of the reason X-38 was killed was that it got too close to this “third rail” – it was proposed to fly among multiple nations launchers. Got waay too close to almost do this …

      2. Actually, the holy trinity is 1) ISS and access to it. 2) Webb 3) SLS.

        Tourism is irrelevant to second-source (i.e. dependence upon Soyuz) and U.S. flagged/launched access to ISS. But some congesspeople are focused on everyone else.

  4. Marcel,

        One reason ISS costs are going up is because Soyuz prices keep going up.  Also, all programs are now fully costed, so some JSC overhead is now counted under ISS that was under cross-agency-support or Shuttle before. 

        I realize you wanted to splash ISS yesterday, but the fact is that we spent $100billion building ISS.  While ISS may be too expensive to operate, as well as build, it should help us find out whether humans can live and work in space productively or not.  It’s also a great place to test out technologies for exploration, assuming that JSC eases up a bit on the safety requirements. 

                    – Jim

    1. Would I like NASA to move on towards larger and cheaper American made space stations like those proposed by Bigelow Aerospace instead of continuing the hyper expensive $3 billion a year ISS international diplomacy program? Yes!

      Marcel F. Williams

      1.  Bigelow isn’t a magic bullet. It would cost more than the ISS for same, because the ISS funny money calculations aren’t the same as new money.

        The answer for the ISS is utilization. It is unclear to me that the players have any better notion of utilization, should they start right now from scratch, than they did before.

        It is politically infeasible to take an existing ground based major research lab operator that does understand this (say UC which runs many national labs), ask it to arrange a space national lab with NASA as a contributing member of a consortium, and have it put such into action – that’s how you’d get an substantial improvement on that $3B/yr.

      2. The ISS budget is $3b/yr even though it is built, and NASA is no longer flying major hardware to the station. It’s not the station that costs $3b. So why would a NASA program on a Bigelow station be any less?

        1. For a beyond LEO program for NASA, Bigelow space stations would simply serve as housing for astronauts at LEO and the Lagrange points and not as a hyper expensive laboratory. The largest Bigelow space stations would also be substantially cheaper to deploy since they would only require a single launch..

          Private industry and governments could probably finance small specialized space laboratories  a lot cheaper than the ISS since 6 astronauts could do a lot more work on a specific project at a small specialized space station than at a super complex titanic space station where all sorts of projects are going on.

          One of the major flaws of the ISS is that it severely limits the number of people who can work at one time on specific science projects in space.  Multiple small and specialized  space stations, whether they are clustered near each other or far apart,  make a lot more sense than just one centralized space station, IMO.

          Marcel F. Williams

  5. Don’t worry, within a short time we’ll be spending $1 billion a year or more to send a couple crew members up to ISS each year on the Russian vehicle. Gee, keeping Shuttle going by extending out the time between missions might not have been such a bad idea after all since USA said they could continue to fly once or twice a year for about $1billion.

    Mark Geyer recently said that the 2015 Orion flight will be a stripped down command module only unmanned flight demonstrating the “high tech” (Apollo design) heatshield and recovery system. At the moment they have no money to spend on a real Service Module; ESA said they have no interest in collaborating with the US on an SM for our spacecraft (they intend to build their own spacecraft) so the SM for Orion is being deferred. No Orion manned flights for nearly a decade from now, and likely with everything being deferred out to the right, wouldnt be too surprised to see Orion not going ‘operational’ until 2025. Maybe this year’s college grads will see the start of whatever that program might be by mid-career.

    As Bolden stated last week, we need commercial crew because a privately developed/commercial vehicle is the only way we will be able to put an American in orbit on an American spacecraft in this decade. Its too bad that Bolden wasn’t a little more vociferous a couple years ago when there were some other possible options.

        1. Actually I think that they don’t.  Their staffers are probably afraid to tell them something so displeasing as most politicians work firmly on the “shoot the messenger” philosophy of dealing with bad news.

    1. Judging by past shuttle program budgets, the cost is around the same $3b/yr whether you launch no missions or four.

      That would strongly suggest that the cost of flying the shuttle once per year is $3b per flight.

  6.  Commercial Crew is the only approach that can work within the time frame to displace Soyuz buys.

    Orion may function eventually, but we are far from the end of the schedule slips. And even if it does, then the time frame of SLS, needed to fly crew as demanded by Congress, is even longer, with much greater schedule slips, and already known budgeted itemas like JWST did, all set to majorly explode budget long term – “but then we just buy more Soyuz”.

    Rather than budget to get us off Soyuz first and then to the precious rocket to nowhere second,  Hutchinson wants to squander money to get Orion first then … what? It might have made some kind of dubious sense if before Shuttle conclusion, a DIRECT-like J-130 SDLV had been done – because you might have translated Shuttle into exploration budget wise and development wise.

    But past that point, it doesn’t seem reasonable, given what we’re seeing. Starving Commercial Crew has consistently put us behind.

    Why do we want to be behind?

    1. surely a retorical question. KBH is trying to sabotage Commercial to keep it from getting ahead of Constellation. 

      Of course, we could launch people with orion on the Delta – wait, no. The LSAS/ESAS “proved” that the Delta could not launch the Orion in order to justify the billions spent on Ares I.

      1.  I’ve been thinking about what will happen should SpaceX get its act together and completely successfully bring off COTS 2/3. How would that alter the situation?

        From what I see, it is likely that SLS/Orion  (or Delta IVH/Orion) is on the edge of another schedule push back).

        I’ve wondered if all this nonsense is an attempt to deal ahead of time with this issue, to keep from having a follow-on rush to do commercial crew by a fed up constituency.

        So it will be about “falling behind”.

  7. The only real question is whether Hutchison is very cynical and evil, doing enormous harm to our country to steal a relatively small amount for her constituents or whether she is so stupid that she has actually succeeded in rationalizing this to herself and actually believes she can both help herself and the country at the same time.

    I think stupid is more likely.  Most non-engineers really can’t grasp even the most obvious of engineering concepts, and people tend to have a large capacity for rationalization that what they want to be true is actually true.

  8. To repeat.Faster,better,cheaper.NASA DIY.Rocket tanks have been made for a hundred years(water tanks,tankers).Build an Atlas class rocket.Build 2 spacecraft.What ever NASA wants.NASA needs only to buy material.They have the knowhow,engineers and workers,manufacturing,testing,launching,controlling facilities,transportation and storage.A liquid rocket is simple and cheap to build.Nothing as complicated as SRBs.I saw a video of them being made at ATK.Layers and layers of very labor intensive work.Rocket engines are simple and cheap to build.Robots can be used.Nothing as complicated as cars.With the new machining methods a turbo pump is easy.Space Tourists showed Soyuz salvagers  using a turbo pump housing for a cooking pot.NASA can not use  cost  as an excuse to not have US crew in 3 years.They can reduce cost enough through DIY to do it under current budget.Everyone has wanted something for the cost of material.Since 90% of the weight is fuel,the rest does not weigh much.Than can buy those 10,000lb. rolls of aluminum directly from the mills.A 3’x4′ 7075T6 .19 thick retail costs $322,but you get a 10% discount over $100.The costs of rolls might be only 10% of that and they are already curled,so it might be easier to form.
     NASA does not need very many rockets a year.It does not make sense to purchase them.                                                                 

    1. “They have the knowhow”

      I disagree with this. The lack of launcher know-how is, IMO, why the last 25+ years have been so wasted. Every HSF employee post-Apollo knows only the shuttle. Those from the early-’80s onward, which is nearly all of them, know only shuttle-ops.

      Add to that the high average age at recruitment, and you’ve got a very inexperienced but inflexible workforce.

      And that disagreement is why I strongly agree with your overall idea. Not necessarily to replace purchased launch vehicles with in-house launchers, but to have a internal rocket engineering program purely as an engineer training tool. Low budget, with complete freedom to blow-up rockets without repercussions more serious than a deflated ego.

      Volunteer program for engineers, unpaid weekends and overtime, NASA supplies the raw materials and manufacturing equipment, substituting labour whenever possible. All internal, no contracts.

      Could be a designed like a multi-year graduate program. First year you build a brand new launcher, designed and managed by the second years. Third year you work on a capsule, designed/managed by fourth years. Etc. A few old hands to teach the tricks of the trade. It’s the sort of thing engineers would find insanely fun. Monster Garage for rocket scientists.

      (I had this same thought after Columbia, when the program was shut down and NASA was cut off from the ISS, even for basic Progress-style cargo missions. I remember thinking, “Wait, NASA can’t build a cargo capsule? NASA can’t built a cargo capsule? NASA can’t build a cargo capsule?” (…it went on like that for awhile), “Shouldn’t something so basic be a Welcome-To-NASA introductory project for each year’s intake of engineers?” After that, I realised that the shuttle ops people were actually afraid of the shuttle – which is why none of the next-gen ideas were ever followed through – STS was a magic box, you follow the book-of-spells and the magic box (mostly) does what you want. But you don’t know why, which is why you can’t vary the spells nor built a new box.)

      1. NASA could design and build a cargo capsule.  But even they figured out it would cost too much, so they went COTS and CRS.

  9. If you think Charlie is crying now,just tell him he could build his own launcher and 2 different spacecraft.There would not be a dry eye in NASA.When Mercury was flown did NASA say there goes a Spaceship I worked on?No they had to say there goes McDonald.My brother-in-law worked on the Moon landers,but he did not work for NASA,he worked for Grumman.NASA people should be given a prize for 50 years of giving us great rides.If you let them DIY they will probably have people lining up to work over time for free.
     I did a DIY airplane.It was the greatest project I ever did.I cut the strips of wood on my table saw and glued them together.I did it all.I even built 2 props,One I broke when I had to jump a ditch.I still remember the thrill,when the engine came.Yes,on the second lift off I was nearly killed when I stalled at 100′ when I chopped the throttle.But,when I figured out how to fly it and made that first trip around the pattern,I can not describe the feeling.I put in 80 hours on that plane.A great adventure and NASA people should be alowed to do the same.

Comments are closed.