Keith’s note: Commercial space is almost certainly going to come up at each of these hearings. I wonder if the Commercial Spaceflight Federation will continue to be silent as they were last week when the topic was raised at two other hearings.
Hearing Airs Concerns with Sustaining Space Station and Fulfilling Research Potential
“Although NASA has done a credible job of ensuring that the ISS can last for years to come, the question that remains is whether NASA will be able to service the station and productively use it for science,” Ms. Chaplain said. “Routine launch support is essential to both, but the road ahead depends on successfully overcoming several complex challenges, such as technical success, funding, international agreements, and management and oversight of the national laboratory.”
– Science, Space, and Tech Committee Hearing: Securing the Promise of the International Space Station
– Hearing Charter
– Statement: Ralph Hall
– Statement: William H. Gerstenmaier
– Statement: Cristina Chaplain
– Statement: Thomas P. Stafford

– Senate Appropriations Commerce, Justice, Science and Related Agencies Hearing on NASA Budget
– Statement: Sen. Mikulski
– Statement: Charles Bolden
– NASA Budget Estimates

– Odd Silence on the Commercial Space Front, earlier post

Biologist, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA Space Biologist and Payload integrator, Editor of NASAWatch.com and Astrobiology.com, Lapsed climber, Explorer, Synaesthete, Former Challenger Center board member 🖖🏻

16 replies on “Multiple Hearings on NASA Today”

  1. Commercial needs to make its case. Judging by the questions at the last few hearings, ‘non-commercial’ is lobbying like crazy.

  2.  They have the people to answer my question of if it would be faster,better,cheaper for NASA to build their on rockets and space craft like they did partly with Ares-1X.I hope they will volunteer the answer or someone will ask the question.SLS would be cheap if NASA did not let any private company do the work.All liquid.It would be as good as Saturn-V.Another cost savings would be to use single large engines.It is only slightly more expensive to build a 1million than to build a 100,000 thrust.The cost is in the building ,not material.NASA may have already canceled crew.Every year they add a year.If they do this for ever,no crew. 

    1.  NASA would have to hire people to build its own rockets.  Their wages will cost money.  Filling in forms and holding meetings will be part of the labour cost of building the rockets.

    2. NASA does not have the people, and the people they have for the most part are not hands-on workers. The Ares I-X was built by contractors.The difference between Commercial Crew and SLS/Orion is that 1) Commercial Crew is designed for ISS support, SLS/Orion is a different design, not appropriate for ISS support, and 2) There is considerably more NASA management of SLS/Orion at the level of design details.

      If the civil service personnel system was modified to be more flexible, so that NASA managers could add or drop people as needs changed, than perhaps they could do more in-house fabrication and operational support, bu right now it would be very difficult.

      My feelingis that high-level planning and resource allocation (i.e. what CASIS is doing) probably should be in-house. Long-range, low-level R&D where the exact goals are not yet well defined perhaps should be in-house. Large-scale design, fabrication and operational projects would be very difficult to do in-house.

      1. AS I remember it and from recent research Ares-1X was done by NASA.Glenn did most of the fabrication of the dummy adapter,2nd stage,Orion.They shipped the sections to KSC where they were stacked on the ATK SRB.I think that NASA people did all the stacking.NASA did the programing,launch and recovery of the SRB.The electronics were done by Lockheed-Martin and Jacobs Engineering.While not a full rocket,I think this gives NASA enough experience to build one.This also show they have the people available and very few people has quit since then.Drop one of those non-funded SAAs.Someone wrote that they had 16 people and I know 1 astronaut assigned to them.My source is Wikapedia.What is yours that it was built by contractors?The Orion lite could be used for ISS support if it had to be.Launchers are easy.Iran and N.Korea can do it,so can NASA at a huge savings in money and time.It will not be needed however.

        1. Sorry, NASA personnel did not do the stacking. It was mostly done by United Space Alliance people, a lot of whom have been laid off since the last Shuttle landed. NASA does not have the hands on skills required for it. Contractors are hired to do most of this type of work.

  3.  Outrageous.A Rep. did ask if it would cheaper if NASA did cargo.Instead of answering the question truthfully,Gerst. put the spin on.He said that if NASA did it the way they usually do it,then Commercial Cargo was cheaper.The Rep. did not understand what he said or ignored it,because it is what he wanted to hear.Is that any way to disprove my theory?What if NASA did it all themselves?No answer yet.I say it is the cost of material.About 1/10 the cost of hiring private companies.

  4. The more I hear from Senator  Kay Bailey Hutchison the more I think she is only concerned about NASA as a Jobs Program.  And to hear Senator Thad Cochran’s first comments be How does this affect Stennis… They do not care about the United States leading, they care about protecting NASA as a jobs program… IMHO…. 

  5.  A good Senate hearing.Good questions and good answers.Bolden did do a little spin when he said they could not do what they do with out contractors.That does not answer my plan to save money on launchers and space craft.My plan to use people and then robots still would work.As I said in the beginning if people are not available it would not work.No new hires.I guess building Mars,Moon rovers and habitats is more important and can not be delayed.
     If he thinks building carbon fiber tanks for SLS will save money,I don’t think so.That is one of the most expensive ways that a tank can be built.It will blow the budget.What do you think the oven will cost to put a 27′ diameter tank will cost?Astronomical.It is also the most labor intensive.H e should check with the semi trailer tanker people to get the best know how on building a rocket.

    1. Saturn13,

      You mention the cost of the oven (but don’t give any numbers), but you not once, anywhere consider the cost of the robots you’ve been proposing. When you can accurately determine the number and nature of robots required, now and in the future, and then calculate an actual cost for those robots (a better calculation than you did for sheet metal) and their maintenance costs over X years, then you may have the start of an argument, buy I wouldn’t bet on it. There are many other issues that you have likewise overlooked, such as training for all of the people you propose to hire (and severance/unemployment for all the people you want to fire). I’m sure you realize that you can’t simply reassign the existing NASA/contractor work force to the jobs in your scheme.

      The biggest problem that I see in implementing your ideas, however, has nothing to do with machinery, materials or production methods, but rather with people. To do what you want, you’d have to get NASA to fire about 80-85% (my off-hand guess) of its employees, and all of its contractors, and replace them with new hires with no relevant experience. How are you going to make that happen? Do you think that any level of government is going to agree to put all those thousands of people out of jobs, especially considering that there’s nowhere in any industry for them to go instead? There’s not a snowball’s chance of that happening.

      Also consider, replacing a majority of the people and adopting new (not yet existing) processes and procedures across the entire operation isn’t going to happen over night — it would takes years before anything was produced; years of extreme costs with absolutely no output from the entire operation. Who’s going to pay for that? How is that going to save money? Who do you think is going to agree to that?

      If you combine issues like these with the fact that nobody here at NASA Watch has written anything in support of your proposal, you might want to consider that as a sign that you need to go back and rethink your ideas. Personally, I’m all for considering anything that might make the situation at NASA better, but it has to be doable, and it has capable of being sold to the powers that be.

      Steve

  6. I did not hear or see the hearings. However I take issue with all of the following comments:

    NASA would have to hire people to build its own rockets
    NASA does not have the people, and the people they have for the most part are not hands-on workers
    Instead of answering the question truthfully, Gerst. put the spin on.He said that if NASA did it the way they usually do it,then Commercial Cargo was cheaper
    Bolden did do a little spin when he said they could not do what they do with out contractors.

    NASA’s people are no less talented and capable than others in the industry if they are given the authority and responsibility to do the job.  I have seen no shortage of hands on work by NASA people, particularly anyone in the program prior to the mid-1990s. It generally was not in the organizations that Gerstenmaier or Bolden would be familiar with. Gerstenmaier was in Mission Ops his entire career. Those folks spend their time meeting on mission rules and procedures and looking at computer screens. Gerstenmaier for many years has managed by placing ‘professional managers’ who had no relevant experience instead of ensuring that people did have the experience and got promoted up the ladder only when they proved themselves capable. This is why manned space is in such poor shape today. It is how the system has worked for about as long as Gerstenmiaer has been in management. It did not start with him but he was fully a part of this inexplicable system. It is not how most organizations, even in NASA, have worked in the past.

    Gerstenmaier, for example, put people who have never worked payloads, whether as a developer, PI, or NASA integrator, managing payloads. Is it any wonder they have no clue how big (or small) a job it is to actually do payloads? Instead of searching for people with a diversity of experienced project development skills, Gerstenmaier selected many of the top people in the Constellation and Orion organizations-they were his hand picks.  Same thing in a myriad of other areas. Yes, from Gerstenmaier’s limited perspective, he has little idea of how much of the organization has worked over time. Bolden, coming from Flight Ops, even less so. Most of their people fly the vehicles but have little hands on design or development experience even in procedures.

    Yes, you have to select the appropriate people with the right backgrounds, give them every opportunity to work hands on, and ensure that the experience doesn’t go to waste so as the experience and skills increase then the people move up the ladder to take on larger roles throughout the program. This is not how management in NASA manned space has worked in the last 15 years.

    So Gerstenmaier is right, as long as management like himself continue to work the way they have been, most are nothing more than bean counters and chart flippers and they would not know how to start a hands on job. As Constellation showed, they really didn’t know how to start virtually any kind of a job. It would take a dramatic change in modus operandi, and the current crop of NASA SES’s wouldn’t know what they don’t know.

    Go back a few years to the top people of the Mercury, Apollo or Shuttle era. Mercury, especially, followed the NACA Lab model and the NASA technologists designed and physically built the early spacecraft and rockets in-house before the jobs were turned over to contractors. The first Saturn rockets were built in-house before they even began to search for a contractor to build them. The top people in Apollo came out of that group or other similar groups like the ones with ballistic missile experience. Most of the top Shuttle people through the development and early flight phase (mid-1980s) were likewise hands-on researchers, engineers and technologists before they moved into management.

    Except for some specific groups like X-38 (which ended 10 years ago) and the advanced spacesuits area, owing to their experienced leadership, virtually no one in the current management ranks have any hands-on experience. In fact the current crop of managers have taken every opportunity to dump everyone with experience they could because the hands-on experience based approach threatens their way of life which is promotion without experience. It doesn’t mean that this is the right approach. Given the poor state of manned space flight in the US today, its most certainly the exactly wrong approach. In fact only commercial crew shows a bit of a bright light shining through. but they have yet to prove themselves.

    I’ve no doubt that NASA could develop into a first rate hands-on organization, particularly for R&D, but it requires a totally different management approach than how the current crop of managers got to where they are.
    I think that it is the only way that NASA can turn itself around into an organization that adds value instead of sucking dollars for the purpose of maintaining and expanding the bean counter/chart flipper job base.

    Unfortunately as long as non-experienced NASA managers are managing the contractors, the contractors know exactly how to work NASA, after all the first job of every good capitalist contractor is to earn the largest profit possible. NASA’s mission is to fly flights, explore, enhance technology, expand on the nation’s capabilities, yada yada. That is not the contractor’s prime goal.
        

    1. “Except for some specific groups like X-38 (which ended 10 years ago) and the advanced spacesuits area”

      The spacesuit people have done remarkable work, continuing the R&D saga through thick and thin. Unfortunately it was recently announced that their organization is being subsumed by the ‘Orion Program Office’.

      This is a sure way to kill independence, incentive and innovation; its exactly what ISS did in taking over many of the technical/engineering functions over the last 10-15 years, which is the prime reason why ISS has been so lumbering, inefficient and expensive. JSC over the last twenty years has in this way killed their technical/engineering organizations by placing their inexperienced program management in charge of everything. Now JSC seems to lack the technical/engineering base so they hire everything out to other centers and contractors. Which brings you full circle to exactly the problem Gerst was referring to and that Broner has so eloquently commented on.

  7.  
    Does anyone else feel that this subject is being rushed out the door before Space X can launch to the ISS at the end of the month.   It is at the very heart of the whole argument yet Space X is the white elephant in the room.   I don’t want undo pressure on elon but do wish him the best of luck.  just to rub their noses in it. 

  8. Saturn13
    I really don’t understand your idea of using NASA to build Rockets in house, and as you suggest almost completely robotic. I like the idea in the short term and I’m sure it would be possible. I do see your point of not having layers of sub contractor profits and fix costs added up over and over. And I see how if you could eliminate most labor cost with robotics that could be cheaper.
    But should public NASA engineers be manufacturing rockets at all? I recall as a kid seeing a movie about how the Soviet Union would build farm equipment. They had a rugged design and just churned them out. They never innovated just built the same old thing. Didn’t we just get finished with flying the same old rocket over and over without innovating.
    Isn’t Spacex trying to create cheaper rockets while using automobile manufacturing techniques which will lead to robotic rocket plants??
    Isn’t it better to have competing companies trying to outdo each other always, looking for a cheaper better way??
    Why is Elon going after reusable recoverable boosters when NASA could have and should have but never did for years?
    Anyway I think your idea is cool and bold but very flawed because it goes against human nature.
     

    1. “And I see how if you could eliminate most labor cost with robotics that could be cheaper”
       
      DTARS,
       
      I can’t agree with that. 1) the robots are very expensive.  2) you still need people, to maintain and program the robots, so you still have all of the overheads associated with employees and you still have lots of people.  Robots are cost effective only when you have them doing the same operation thousands of times in a row, which would not be the case in Saturn13’s NASA or any “rocket building” organization.  The only argument for robotics at NASA that I can see is the same one that is currently recognized: for situations were the physical precision required for an operation is beyond human capability.
       
      Steve

Comments are closed.