This is not a NASA Website. You might learn something. It's YOUR space agency. Get involved. Take it back. Make it work - for YOU.
Uncategorized

Mars Perseverance Media Briefing

By Keith Cowing
NASA Watch
January 27, 2021
Filed under
Mars Perseverance Media Briefing

Keith’s note: NASA held a Mars Perseverance media briefing today. I asked a question that follows up on my earlier post “NASA’s Mars 2020 Websites Are Not Ready For Prime Time” wherein I noted that NASA PAO and the Aeronautics and Technology directorates are not paying all of the attention to this mission as you’d expect them to be. My question:
“My question should be addressed to people who are not present on this panel so I will direct it to Dr. Zurbuchen instead. The Mars 2020 mission involves the flight of the Ingenuity helicopter drone which is a joint effort by the NASA Science Mission Directorate, the Aeronautics Research Mission Directorate, and the Space Technology Mission Directorate. We just heard a quote from the new Vice President. At a time when this new Administration talks about “whole of government approaches” one would think that the “whole of NASA” would be using their various outreach tools to talk about this helicopter and the overall mission. Yet the Aeronautics and Technology mission directorates have been utterly silent to their respective audiences about Ingenuity or their role in it its development. This is odd since this rover and its helicopter seem to have relevance to virtually everything that NASA does with applicability to things in many people’s everyday lives. As such, why isn’t the “whole of NASA” doing their best to highlight the diverse capabilities of this mission?”
Zurbuchen agreed with the general premise of my question and said that NASA is always trying to do things better. “I met with the Aeronautics and Technology AAs this morning about this. As we go forward we will be learning from each other. This truly is a whole of government mission like we have never had before.”. Full audio of Zurbuchen’s response below.

At one point with regard to a question on Mars sample return one of the JPL briefers said “Samples will be returned to Earth some time in the 2030s”. In other words, samples will be returned at the same time that humans are heading to Mars if you accept NASA’s long-standing timeline for human missions to Mars. NASA has long stated that sample return from Mars was needed in advance of sending humans to Mars so as to understand any potential risks and to plan missions to deal with what may be found. Now (apparently) the samples will come back after mission design is mostly decided. Also, if Mars sample return to Earth and missions with humans from Earth to Mars are roughly simultaneous, then why spend a billions on a robotic sample return when you are sending humans to Mars to do the same type of studies? There is a broken logic path here. Or perhaps the science and human exploration folks are not in perfect synch with one another.

NASA Watch founder, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA, Away Teams, Journalist, Space & Astrobiology, Lapsed climber.

3 responses to “Mars Perseverance Media Briefing”

  1. Bill Housley says:
    0
    0

    Maybe I’m overly cynical, but Dr. Zurbuchen’s sounded like a non-answer to me.

    As for the sample return thing, I think it’ll work out fine if NASA continue’s its current pattern of timeline slip with regards to crewed Mars missions. In fact, Elon or some foreign country might have a sample back before 2030 anyway.

  2. Nick K says:
    0
    0

    While there seems to be plenty of information about the Perseverance rover online, it doesn’t seem to be too well organized. I wonder if the media has difficulty trying to put the story together? You almost have to know the story of the prior rover, Curiosity, to know how this one will work.

    As far as the helicopter it is a minor part of the overall story. Its just a ‘technical demonstration’ and nothing happens with it for a month or longer after a successful landing. Its not considered part of the science of the mission, not a part of Zerbuchen;s organization’s activity, so I don’t see it as being too important yet. Maybe if it works, and if it takes some decent pictures of the rover on the surface it will prove useful and get more attention.

    Collecting samples for future return is even further off. They do not know when the sample return mission will take place or how exactly it will happen. All there seems to be are some preliminary ideas on what a mission will look like and that it won’t happen for another 6 to 10 years. I get the impression they are not even certain that the samples Perseverance collects will for certain be the ones the future lander/return vehicle will try to recover.