SpaceX to Sue Over EELV Sole-Sourced Contract, SpaceRef Business
“In a news conference held at the National Press Club in Washington SpaceX CEO Elon Musk started off by outlining the recent success of the soft landing of the Falcon 9 first stage off the coast of Florida. He then dropped a bombshell aimed straight at the heart of Washington with news that he was going to protest and sue over the recent sole sourced Evolved Expendable Launch Vehicle (EELV) contract won by United Launch Alliance (ULA).”
Marc’s note: I’ve included the full audio from the news conference. The first half of the news conference relates to the soft landing of the Falcon 9 first stage. Then Elon Musk begins to discuss the legal action started by SpaceX.

Marc Boucher is an entrepreneur, writer, editor, podcaster and publisher who has worked in space media for more than 25 years. In 1999 he co-founded SpaceRef with Keith Cowing. The new media company grew into a network that included NASA Watch and The Astrobiology Web. After selling SpaceRef, he joined Multiverse Media, which later merged with SpaceNews. There he helped steer the combined company toward more multimedia, a subscription paywall and intelligence products, and pushed for a mobile app. He is also the founder of SpaceQ Media, Canada’s space news and market intelligence publication.

Marc started his first Internet content business in 1992 and hasn’t looked back. When he’s not working, he loves exploring Canada and the world and expanding his photography skills.

48 replies on “SpaceX to Protest and Sue Over EELV Contract”

  1. How ironic, or apropos? A space launch provider assisted along by one government agency, NASA, suing a supplier to a fellow government function, the Air Force. Who knows…eventually even Ma’Bell, that had been supported by the government, fostering a monopoly, was in courts being dismantled. It seems to take one or two generations to have the government assist in the formation of some economic or defense imperative (trains, planes, telephony, power, etc). Then it takes another generation to take the Frankenstien apart.

    Add access to space to the list…

      1. No kidding. Who do you think paid for ALL OTHER rockets, EVER? Atlas started life as an ICBM. Same thing for Titan and the rest of them. Who paid for EELV development? Who is paying ULA one billion per year to cover overhead costs? Answer: you, me and all of us with our taxes. I find it amusing when people make the argument that SpaceX is “not commercial” or “doing it with government money”. What is new is the business model SpaceX is using. Spending their own money in hopes to gain an advantage in government contracts later. Well, it is starting to happen now.

        1. And (perhaps another reason they are spending their own money) is that their business model allows for having other customers. They have been starting from scratch in the business model sense to change things up, not just to be a competitor to ULA.

    1. There’s no irony. Bidders on large contracts routinely sue if they think the contract was awarded unfairly. This is particularly common in government contracts, where an external lawsuit may help one internal faction move against another internal faction. (Where the contractor is essentially being told, “You have to sue us or we can’t change anything.”)

      If that’s not the case here, then unless SpaceX can show serious malfeasance by the contract assessors (I mean black and white violations of law), then they may have done more harm than good. [OTOH, if they’ve been cut out of future contracts, what do they have to lose?]

      [SpaceX was on the other side of this over the Pad 39A lease challenge.]

  2. Competing corporations of the military industrial complex have long had to legally contest contract decisions. For SpaceX, they never had a chance to compete! They are clearly doing the right thing to be competitive in this business.

    Musk stated that “70% of the cost of a Falcon 9 is the first stage”. This surely doesn’t include the profit that is part of the total cost to customers. Of the $56M about $20M is the cost of the first stage taking into account profit and processing and launch fees. So right now, without reuse, they are charging about $1950/lb to LEO. Reuse would reduce the cost to LEO to $1413/lb. If the upper stage costs about $7M, reusing it may save, maybe $5M, making the lowest future cost of lifting a pound of payload to LEO with F9 about $1241/lb. Streamlining production and mass production could lower the final cost to $1000/lb with Falcon 9 but it will never achieve the $500/lb milestone. But still, with reuse of the first stages, it will be the 2020’s before anyone can match Falcon 9 and Heavy prices.

    Falcon Heavy will be able to achieve $500/lb. Its present bargain basement price to LEO is $1153/lb. Return all three F9 cores and that will reduce pricing to about $769/lb. Then to $726/lb if it reuses the upper stage. And with future lower production costs, Falcon Heavy can attain the $500/lb goal.

    1. Factually, the numbers are damning, in SpaceX’s favor, as you point out. Anyone looking at the numbers would say the DoD must be extremely rich to be so price insensitive. Yet legally speaking, what’s likely to matter? The DoD will make a strong argument about the independence to make national security decisions, independent of merely, or only, economic or fiscal considerations. The judiciary is always asked to give national security ample room, avoiding interfering in such matters.

      SpaceX will have to make a legal case in a way that gets the right kind of judge intrigued, curious enough to think about anti-trust law, for example, among other precedents, but especially in a way the judge would think will stand on appeal. This will be most interesting! But something tells me, many years will pass as well.

      1. “The DoD will make a strong argument about the independence to make national security decisions…” Agreed, but on the basis of national security alone I think building here instead of importing from Russia favors Elon and Space X.

      2. You’re ignoring the physics numbers. The Falcon 9 can only carry 13,150 kg to LEO while the Atlas 5 can carry 18,810 kg. The last Atlas 5 (541) could launch 17,443 kg to LEO.

        1. The physics yes, but the process primarily. To the degree the DoD gets pulled into a legal tussle SpaceX will try to make the discussion about process. For any given payload size, is the process of award a fair one, a competitive one, a well defined process. Being a well defined process meaning being a process that’s defendable, credible. With Falcon Heavy coming along soon, the physics discussion about differing payload sizes for DoD will not stand up long in such a discussion. Is there a process for any size payload from DoD to be awarded fairly, competitively, within a well defined process?

          DoD will likely argue the process, albeit evolving, is a process; that any process, even one needing maturing, is a process. DoD will also argue that this all meets up, that the goal SpaceX seeks lies in the future, well after the block buy, at which point the process will have become “more” defined, as would SpaceX capabilities.

          Who knows which way it will go. A judge or panel that dislikes meddling in national security matters, or even worse such complex “rocket science”, will lean DoD’s way. A judge who likes getting into details will, I think, find many merits in SpaceX arguments.

  3. This is how and when you know your startup company has become truely successful…when you have to file a ginormous lawsuit to level the playing field in a stadium owned and operated by the government. I hear there are tantrums and chairs being thrown in the box suites…

    Go Elon.

  4. I am sure the Air Force and their ULA buddies saw SpaceX coming in the near future which is why they all of a sudden put together a multiple launcher deal last year boasting multiple launches and millions in savings to the taxpayer.
    I suspect that the DoD isn’t fully trusting of SpaceX’s launch vehicles to the point they will let them fly billion dollar payloads just yet.
    Also, SpaceX will have to have to assemble a crew with sufficient security clearances down in Florida to handle the national security payloads.

    1. And an Air Force general has said so publicly. It’s different from launching cargo to the ISS than a multi-billion $ national security payload or humans into orbit.

  5. I would imagine some senaters and congressman are pretty upset about Spacex’s legal action which raises the question about commercial crew down select.

    Who decides???

    Does NASA??

    Or is NASA just a puppet??

    I suspect that because of this Spacex will not be awarded commercial crew.

    ?????????

    1. who decides what? who decides to select commercial crew?

      NASA does, of course.

      Congress may direct NASA to choose only one provider, though. NASA has do to what it is directed to do by Congress.

  6. I found this on the Wikipedia page for EELV:

    ” In December 2012, the DoD announced a re-opening of the EELV-class launch vehicle market to competition
    beginning in 2015. “Under the new plan, the Air Force is authorized to
    proceed with a block buy of “up to” 36 launch cores from current
    monopoly vendor United Launch Alliance, while at the same time opening up another 14 cores to be purchased competitively. The new era will begin in 2015 with initial launches to be performed in 2017.”[14] The Air Force signed a contract at that time with SpaceX for two launches in 2014 and 2015 to serve as proving flights to support the certification process for the Falcon 9 v1.1 and Falcon Heavy.[15]
    The certification of a new entrant follows criteria set forth in the
    New Entrant Evaluation Plan (NEEP). This plan is obtainable by
    contacting the Launch Systems Directorate.”

    So, what exactly is Musk protesting? According to this, SpaceX is being allowed into the process, although ULA is being given preferential treatment. When I first read a summary of Musk’s news conference, I got the idea that he was suing because SpaceX was being locked out completely, but this doesn’t appear to be the case.

    1. I read the same and I agree, with SpaceX not having any certification flights under its belt yet, I do not see where it has a leg to stand on regarding the Air Force’s block buy of EELV’s other than just complaining about a block buy that could serve the Air Forces needs into 2020’s and limit SpaceX’s sales.

      1. Even though I’m a SpaceX fan, I have to agree with these statements. F9 (and certainly FH), is not quite there yet. But it is just a matter of time… It will happen. ULA’s business model cannot compete with that of SpaceX. One big advantage ULA has, is they were there first and do have an outstanding record of reliability. But that can only go so far and certainly not forever.

        1. The Falcon 9 is nearly complete with it’s certification and there are some Air Force launches they could compete for. Just not the big heavy ones.

    2. The block buy appears to be timed to prevent SpaceX from making a bid for quite a few years, while at the same time committing the DOD to a pretty hefty cost increase, about $35 billion for just 60 additional launches.

        1. According to the McCain letters the DOD has no evidence that the lower mass launches were all opened to competition – just the ones that were later cut. As to the Falcon Heavy, the Delta IV Heavy was awarded several DOD launches before it flew, then failed on the first launch. The Atlas was originally proposed in a similar three-core heavy variant, then shifted to using more SRBs. If there is any evidence that SpaceX is asking for a break that Boeing and Lockheed were not already given, I’d like to see it.

          It appears the Falcon Heavy will have its first launch from Cape Canaveral early next year; it will be substantially above the lift capability of the Atlas or Delta. Now of course we could use the same logic as the ESAS and say that all the Falcon 9 launches used a similar core stage and therefore it is already of proven reliability. But we won’t go down that road; we’ll just wait till it has three launches, which are already on the SpaceX manifest, with the third in 2017.

    3. I believe one of Musk’s points (and it is a good one), is that neither Boeing or Lockheed were required to perform a certification flight for either the Atlas V or the Delta IV. They were awarded the EELV contracts without having to conduct a single test flight.

      Now, that in and of itself is not the primary basis for SpaceX’s protest suit. Their protest is against the USAF’s Dec 2013 sole-source block-buy award of the 36 EELV cores to ULA. Although the award was made in Dec, SpaceX was not informed until March…the day after the Senate hearing. And that is where the certification issue comes in. The USAF is using the excuse that SpaceX has not yet met full certification for their Falcon 9. Yet, this didn’t stop the original EELV awards to Lockheed and Boeing (later merged as ULA) for launch vehicles that were similarly not flight tested.

      Furthermore, SpaceX is almost finished with the certification process…and Musk makes the point that the USAF could wait a few months for their certification process to be completed, and then open up the contract for competitive bid.

      Sounds reasonable to me…especially given the uneven playing field and advantage that the USAF has provided the ULA. Yes, the Atlas and Delta rockets, as a family, have legacy history, and a huge number of launches under their belt. However, the Atlas V and Delta IV were new launch vehicles, despite using legacy and evolved hardware and systems from past versions. Nevertheless, by USAF standards, they were brand new rockets with completely new structural dynamics, flight hardware, and a huge number of new, untested sub-systems.

      I actually feel SpaceX has a great case in “the court of public opinion”. Now, whether the specificities of their legal arguments pass muster in the Court of Federal Claims…that will be determined.

      1. For one thing, there was an extensive flight history for both vehicles. Also, the AF didn’t fly any critical national security payloads on the first few flights of either vehicle. The Atlas 5 can carry more than the Falcon 9 can, up to 18,810kg into LEO. The Falcon heavy was originally due to launch last year from Vandenburg and now has moved to next year from the Cape. Not something to launch an expensive national security payload on for now.

        1. Hi John,

          I do not argue the extensive “legacy” history of the Atlas and Delta family of rockets. Nevertheless, the Atlas V and Delta IV configurations were completely new, untested launch vehicles, as defined by USAF criteria…or, as Musk would say, as amended by the USAF after the original EELV award to Lockheed and Boeing. This was an example he cited of the USAF procurement group “moving the goal-posts”. Even NASA would classify them as entirely new launch vehicles..despite their legacy hardware and ancestral variations.

          Furthermore, Musk isn’t expecting to compete for critical NRO type “national security” assets, especially with the Falcon 9. He stated in the press conference that he wanted SpaceX to be able to compete for other USAF missions, such as military GPS and C3 satellites…which the Falcon 9 has the capability to lift, and will be launched on many of the 36 core units that are part of the recent sole-source award.

          Look, I can see both sides of this issue. However, I do believe that SpaceX has a legitimate claim and grievance. It is entirely possible that SpaceX is pursuing this protest “suit” simply as a formality. They may realize they do not have a shot in hell of having the decision over-turned…but they definitely are going to stir up some publicity and get Joe Taxpayer behind them.

          I don’t think Musk is worried about pissing off the USAF. This is business, and they are all big boys. Heck, every time a major contract is awarded, their is typically a formal protest filed by the losing contractor. In this case, SpaceX is taking it a step further, with an official lawsuit. I admit I sympathize with SpaceX in this particular issue. Here, it is not a matter of losing a contract that was part of a competitive bid process. It is a matter of not being able to participate, at all, because there was no competitive bid process in the first place.

          I take Musk at his word, when he stated that their certification of the Falcon 9 would be completed in a matter of a few months. Why can’t the USAF wait this short time, and open up the new EELV core purchase for competitive bid between ULA an SpaceX.

          I would not be at all surprised if the answer to this question has something to do with Lockheed and Boeing lobbyists, and their cozy relationship with the procurement division of USAF space systems. Maybe I am too cynical, but I can definitely see the possibility for some unethical monkey business going on…and either money or “pwesents” (my precious) being exchanged under the proverbial table.

          By the way…SpaceX’s lawsuit may cause a lot of scrutiny in this matter, when accounting and other documents are subpoenaed.

    4. I’ll throw in my two cents. He wants them to define why they didn’t consider SpaceX for these and why they weren’t allowed to compete for them. If he can get a reason out of them by the court forcing it, then he knows what he can shoot for the in the future. Without that, there could be even a longer period before SpaceX is considered.

      Vertical integration? Top secret certified staff? SpaceX will probably have that ready for next time if that was the actual reason. And if it was the flight history, I guess you can see the other comments. I don’t think SpaceX was told that flight history is why they weren’t considered or allowed to compete, but if they were then Musk may have been a bit upset but probably wouldn’t have sued.

  7. The DOD’s extension of the contract pays for 60 additional launches at a cost increase of $38 billion. This is about $576 million per additional launch, a substantial increase.

  8. INCREDIBLE!

    All the luck in the world to SpaceX and Musk. Only bureaucratic buffoons in Washington could possibly make such an incredibly shortsighted and idiotic decision.

    Aside: The RD-180 and the NK-33 are excellent engines and, by their own admission, beyond ULA engineering. So why didn’t they at least make some progress in manufacturing them here? (Also applying this question to Orbital/Aerojet.)

    1. Does Spacex’s suit help or hurt John McCain’s investigation??? Could McCain remindy faster without having to deal with Spacex in court?? Or do the two compliment/ help each other???

      1. It would be one thing if it were just McCain, but Feinstein and several other Senators jumped into this fray over a week ago witha tersely worded letter to Hagel. Let’s hope some congressional hawks also see this for what it is: a risk to national security. Too many eggs in one fragile basket and all.

        Going forward, there is a very real possibility that in November Republicans will take the Senate – even internal Democrat polls show the risk is high. IF that happens John McCain is the ranking member of the Armed Services committee, making first in line to take the Chairmanship in Jan. 2015 That puts him in a position to explore one of his hot button issues – military procurement. He has a real bee in his bonnet over this stuff.

  9. In another thread a couple days ago I said that I like many of the things SpaceX does, which implies there are some things they do that I don’t like. This is a thing I don’t like. All this will accomplish is to make the lawyers and lobbyists richer, ultimately at the expense of the taxpayers. My prediction is that by the time all the legal maneuvering is over and this lawsuit is fully resolved, the outcome will be a moot point.

  10. What I read about the Navy helping to recover the F9 1st stage was wrong. Elon said they will need a much larger ship. Could not find one on the Atlantic coast. Could not get to site for 2 days. The storm tore it up. Only found some of the inter-stage. Not much for museums for the 1st flight to land on water. They may have been going to tow it back and pick it up like the SRBs. They will need a large crane and a lot of space on deck if they pick it up at sea. 2 months to re-fly one from the water, same day for one on land. Sure, put a rocket together, test the engines and launch in one day. Don’t think so. Probably have to fly one without a payload,he says next year. If he waits that long, he will have a lot of 1st stages sitting around. There is only room for 2 F9s in the hanger. It will look like the Titan 2 that were in storage. If all can be reused, then not many airframes will be needed. A lot of layed off people in Cal. NASA could use a F9R for crew and save a lot of money. There is an abort system, so no worry of like loosing a satellite. Did SpaceX give different prices for crew for reuse?

    1. Spacex needs a 100 by 100 foot target barge out there at sea and a few men to shackle it down after landing. The crane could be rented and sent to the port. Cheap. Why waste the booster by letting it get wet????

      A target barge is much cheaper than the cost of the first stage or his bigger boats.

      Also didn’t someone say they had a patent on landing rocket on a barge. That doesn’t seem patentable to me???

      Air craft have landed on boat for years (aircraft carriers)

      Also to get a patent, I thought you had to have a working model??

      Maybe SpaceX should patent sea landings.

      1. I believe it is Bezos and Blue Origin who have “patented” landing a first stage on a barge.

        It makes me wonder how much detail was put into the patent, and if it’s enforceable in international waters?

        It seems the closest point of international waters when launching from the Cape is roughly lat 30.41 lon -76.92 and the Cape is roughly lat 28.52 lon -80.76.

        When I plug those numbers into an online calculator I get around 265 miles down range.

        If you know about these things, is this a doable target for SpaceX?

        1. Is there anything to that “patent”? Is it actually a patent and could it actually hold water? Seems really obvious to me. Helicopters and airplanes land on boats. Give me a break.

      2. They have rejected the barge. They may only land one more time on the water. Elon says a much larger ship to tow or to pick it up and put it on deck. These flights have been ballistic. They are not looking for a target. H e said the next flight will be much closer. That may mean they will stop in space and fly back or because of the type of launch there is a different trajectory. They must not be ready for a spot landing. Not much progress to repeat what they have done. All they did to stop the spin was have more nitrogen gas for the thrusters. When the stage is in free fall air flow spins it up. Maybe we will see fins on a rocket again. If the spin is always the same direction, fixed fins would correct it. But what they have works though. They have a video of it landing. Poor picture quality and they are enhancing it. They hope when they release it there might be someone that can do a better job on it than they can.
        How many 1st stages will they need?10? Why doesn’t ULA do this? It may be more difficult because their rockets use the puny 20,000lb thrust Centaur for the second stage. Stageing is much higher and farther away. They would need a new rocket to best use this technology. Boeing puts an add on TV showing all their advanced technology. They are a dinosaur when it comes to reuse. Elon says it is evolutionary. I say it is revolutionary. Everyone one will have to copy or be non competitive. Orbital might be able to do it. They may change engines and then have enough margin to fly back. Sorry to be so long, but I do like this.

  11. So much hope is being invested in SpaceX by people rightly disappointed in the pace of progress under purely government space efforts. SpaceX has many accomplishments to be proud of and I understand that those who have lost faith in NASA are looking for a new place to invest their hopes and dreams.
    With all that — keep your eyes open. Watching the actions of SpaceX rather than their words makes me think they are more invested in becoming another government contractor than they are in becoming the commercial success so many hoped for. This suit strikes me as one more sign that they do not believe the commercial market can sustain the company they have become. I do not see in it the signs of hope and progress towards free market that other commenters in this thread do — I see it as another step on the road to SpaceX joining the government industrial complex.

    1. Mr/s Pincher

      Say you are right. What if the commercial market is not quite there yet. What do we have?? And say Spacex wins the suit and gets a big share of the government contract’s. What happens to my tax dollars?? They go to Musk. What does he do with that money?? Whatever he can to be buried on Mars before he dies. I want my money going to Musk because he is reinvesting his money into making us a multi planet Species.

      And the road to Mars, the moon, and outer space is commercial Space which can only happen if somebody can make flight to Leo cheap enough, which Spacex is trying very hard to do!

      Sure beats my money going to ULA where they live fat off my hard earned tax dollar.

    2. I was thinking I agree with you, but then I thought why can’t they take business from Russia and Ariane? They do a lot of launches. There is plenty there if you can compete on price and reliability. I don’t know the pricing situation.

Comments are closed.