Keith’s note: Planets orbit stars. Moons orbit planets. Planets and moons are worlds. Our solar system has lots of worlds and no two are the same – Right? “Planet” and “Moon” define where a world is located – not what it is made of. But it seems that NASA’s New Horizons mission has decided that they want to unilateraly rewrite the definitions for these terms and, in so doing, confuse everyone.

Biologist, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA Space Biologist and Payload integrator, Editor of NASAWatch.com and Astrobiology.com, Lapsed climber, Explorer, Synaesthete, Former Challenger Center board member 🖖🏻

43 replies on “NASA New Horizons Has Decided To Change Astronomical Definitions”

    1. Well, many of the people who speak for New Horizons are very much against the demotion of Pluto (example — Alan Stern), so this statement really doesn’t surprise me.

    1. I don’t mind calling Pluto, Titan, Ceres etc. “worlds” – they are complex, interesting places! I think that’s a generic enough term for them – yet they are not major full-fledged planets.

  1. Only the earth and ISS are planets because they have human life on them. Once we settle the other orbs of our solar system, they can become planets too.

    Definition of a planet a habitual space, with gravity, where humans can survive.

    Pubic and commercial space better get on the ball if we are to have true planets

    Add

    ISS should not be a planet because it does not have gravity. A giant space wheel would be a planet. The giant gas planets should not be planets since humans could never survive on their surfaces.

    Location orbits shouldn’t matter all orbs must meet the human habitable standard to be a planet.

    Add gas giants like Saturn and Jupiter are stars not planets.

    Add small spaceships like dragon 2 are not planets do to lack of gravity.

    1. The term Moon is old fashion. Throw it out

      Human habitable orbs that orbit other human habitable orbs should be called sub planets.

      All the rocks that orbit the gas giants would now be planets since they are potentially habitable and orbit “stars”

    2. the ISS has gravity, of course. so do spaceships. anything with mass has gravity. YOU have gravity. your computer or phone has gravity.

  2. I think we’ll know more about what a planet is or is not when Pluto reveals its secrets in the next year or two.

    1. the size and shape of Pluto has no bearing on what the definition of a planet is – we already know those measurements, anyway. what will change about what we know of Pluto is we’ll know exactly what it and its moons look like, what their composition is, characterize any atmosphere at the time of the fly-by, and likely find any additional moons that Pluto might have.

  3. Keith’s note is correct.

    Planets orbit the Sun. Minor or dwarf planets are simply smaller planets. Satellites/Moons orbit planets. Some are bigger; most are smaller.

    The NASA folks are simply gumming up the works and trying to recreate definitions after hundreds of years of scientific and colloquial use for their own political purposes. Our students have a difficult enough time learning these things now, after a couple dozen years of new information about many of these worlds. We really do not need NASA confusing basic definitions. They are doing a basic dis-service.

  4. You are finally given the funding to send a probe to the last “planet” in the solar system. Before it gets there is gets a new name and you are no longer exploring the last planet … would be bit dishearting.

    1. Instead you’re exploring the first¹ example of a whole new class of object, the KBOs, of which there are probably thousands of members.

      So yeah, “poor me”.

      You don’t hear the principal investigator of the Dawn mission making a fool of himself over the non-planetary status of Ceres.

      —
      ¹ Well Triton was probably the first example of a KBO discovered, and the first explored by Voyager 2.

  5. Apparently Ms. Porco feels that it’s all about composition and size, and that for classification purposes it is irrelevant where an object is located, or how it interacts with other objects. However this ignores the original definition of a planet. The “wandering stars” were classified due to their unique motions, even though at the time it was not known what caused these motions, and nothing was known about the size and composition of the planets.

    Later when it was discovered that there were objects circling some planets they were eventually referred to as moons. In fact it’s ironic that she picked Titan as an example because its discoverer Christiaan Huygens was the first to use that term outside of our Earth/Moon system when he referred to Titan as “Saturn’s Moon”.

    By now of course we have learned a whole lot more not only about size and composition of objects in our solar system but also that there are many more objects circling the Sun than anyone had ever imagined. However the original definitions of planet and moon continue to influence the classification of these newly discovered objects by taking into consideration their relationship to other objects.

    Ms. Porco seems to feel that this viewpoint is unscientific. Well as soon as she can prove that an object’s location and interaction has no relationship to how and when the object formed then she can feel free to promote her new naming system. But since we still know very little about how the solar system formed I think the current naming system will do for now.

  6. There are asteroids with moons. Should these be called planets too? They orbit the sun.
    I think they have done well posting what they did- look at the discussion it created! And why shouldn’t they question something they believe should be questioned?

    1. It has to have enough mass to create a round sphere and it has to have cleared out a pathway in it’s orbit. Asteroids as a rule don’t.

      1. I was replying to ics1956 note on the use of language. I’m saying it isn’t that simple which is why there is debate.
        My further point is they as scientists they have the right to create debate. The current definition of a planet does not sit well with many people.
        Your point on having cleared out a pathway is part of the current definition but that is also very subjective. There is a lot of space between Pluto and the next object. How much space is enough?
        I’d prefer to class worlds they have enough mass to create a round object as primary and secondary planets. Primary=orbiting a star. secondary=orbiting a primary planet.
        There would be another class for planets not bound by a star= tertiary?
        Etc

  7. Well… as long as we are splitting planetary hairs….
    The Moon (capital M, luna etc) from an astrodynamic point of view, orbits the Sun. It never turns away from the sun, toward the Earth, in its orbit. You can say the Moon wobbles in it’s orbit around the sun.
    13 times a year is orbital curviture gets shallower than the average, and
    13 times are year it curves more.

    This definition makes the Moon, the only moon that is not a moon, but rather a planet.

    Then there is the ‘Wandering Star’ definition of planet. If we limit it to
    the naked eye, then Neptune is not a planet but Ceres is.

    We could define Atmospheric Body. Habitat, Circular orbiting,
    Massive, etc. Whatever.

    -Gar.

  8. Planets orbit stars.
    Moons orbit Planets.

    The end. Who is up for describing Earth of a Moon of the Sun? And what does that make the Moon?

    Is Mercury an Asteroid?

    This is pretty straight forward. What orbits what? Titan orbits Saturn. No other body has as much gravitational effect on Titan as Saturn. But why is Saturn not a moon? Because Saturn’s chief gravitational partner is the Sun. Therefore: if your chief gravitational partner is the sun (and a host of other qualifiers which is beyond the scope of this sham), you’re a planet. If your chief gravitational partner is another Planet, you’re a Moon.

    We can carve out a special case of planets of similar mass (double planets), but aside from that, this is very simple.

    1. The barycentre of the Pluto/Charon system is between the two bodies.

      Triton is likely a captured KBO, and is larger than Pluto.

      Asteroids orbit stars.

      Some asteroids have smaller bodies in orbit around them, probably every large asteroid.

      KBOs orbit the sun.

      Some KBOs have smaller bodies in orbit around them.

      During solar system formation, it’s believed that planets are ejected entirely from the system.

      Please apply (and justify) your definitions to those cases for me.

      this is very simple.

      1. I accounted for that when I said ” Therefore: if your chief gravitational partner is the sun (and a host of other qualifiers which is beyond the scope of this sham), you’re a planet. “

        I was very carefully and consciously avoiding to attempt to define a planet. Rather I was differentiating the key way in which Moons and things that could be considered planets (prior to other qualifications) differ.

        If we had all objects within the solar system (except the sun) in a pile to start parsing out moons from planets from asteroids from whatever else, the first, most obvious question is “who orbit is dominated by it’s gravitational interaction with the sun”. That would put all the traditional planets, and many asteroids, KBOs, comets and so forth into one very large pile, and everything we’d define traditionally as a “moon” in the other. And from there we can take that very large pile that is now “moon-less” and start parsing further factors to differentiate a 3 meter piece of rock and ice orbiting the sun from a terrestrial planet or gas giant. As I clearly stated (twice now), this second part is beyond the scope of what is being discussed. Arguing what a planet is, is only tangentially related to what a Moon is. It’s easier to examine what a Moon isn’t.

        And I also accounted for the Pluto/Charon case in my last paragraph when I refered to double planets.

        I’m actually wondering if you read my post at all.

        1. Arguing what a planet is, is only tangentially related to what a Moon is.

          But is specifically related to the (now deleted) comment from the NH team.

          You know, the article that we’re commenting on?

          The NH team didn’t say that Titan isn’t a moon of Saturn, but that it is also a planet. Since they haven’t redefined the term “moon” but rather the term “planet”, surely that is the issue under discussion?

          I’m actually wondering if you read my post at all.

  9. So if a planet gets ejected from a solar system during formation, what does it become?

    There were two solutions to the “Pluto problem”, or strictly, the KBO problem, either you restrict the definition of “planet” even smaller (thus excluding Pluto in order to keep out the KBOs), or you expand it to include every non-celestrial object where the shape is in hydrostatic equilibrium. Ie, if it’s round and isn’t a star, then it’s a planet. (Then you can create sub-categories for different types of planets. Major moons, gas giants, terrestrials, KBOs, solar-planets, exo-planets, rogue-planets, etc. (Minor moons could then be called “asteroidal moons”, a sub-type of “asteroids”, which also better reflects their actual properties.))

    The IAU chose the narrower definition, but others (including myself) prefer the broader.

    Alan Stern’s problem is that he’s taken it all as a personal affront and has gone a bit silly over not getting his own way. But it’s not as it Pluto’s actual properties have magically changed because someone changed a definition; nor is the probe suddenly being abandoned. All he’s achieved is embarrassing those who support the New Horizon mission.

    1. It won’t just be New Horizons/Pluto either.. the argument will also extend to Ceres and it’s candidacy for planethood when the Dawn spacecraft visits next year.

      All in all, this entire thread is simply the preview to 2015 — it’s gonna be a helluva year!

  10. This undoubtedly stems from the idea of not undervaluing their importance, which I do support. In that vein I would favor calling them “worlds”. But I still would reserve the word “planet” for worlds that revolve around the Sun.

    Bob Clark

    1. Maybe world could refer to any object that a human can walk on. Not very scientific I realize but it would be something that the average person could relate to which would help them to differentiate between the different types of objects in the universe, something which I feel most people can’t do very well if at all.

      I’m not sure what the criteria would be for minimum gravity, obviously something below 1/6 of Earth’s gravity since we already know that works. Although that was with 180 pounds of spacesuit and backpack. I would guess that even in 1/6 g if you were inside of a habitat wearing only coveralls you could easily fling yourself into the ceiling if you aren’t careful.

      And I don’t know what the maximum gravity for a world would be but I would think not much more than 1 g.

      1. There’s an existing term “Planemo” (a cutesy pronunciation of Planetary Mass Object), which is the super-category for anything round and non-celestial. But it includes small brown dwarves, stars which have lost enough mass to become sub-stellar, etc. Possible even planetary mass black holes.

        It thus already applies to Pluto, KBOs, gas giants, Earth, Moon, Titan, Triton, exo-planets, rogues, etc.

        Creating a new category within Planemo, “Worlds”, for solid surfaced, walkable Planemos (hence Moon, Titan, Earth, Pluto, Charon…) would let the IAU completely resign “Planet” from modern astronomic use, and retain it purely as a fixed historical “20th century term” for the nine solar planets.

        Re: Minimum/maximum gravity.

        The requirement for approximate hydrostatic equilibrium for Planemos solves the minimum gravity problem. If it doesn’t have enough gravity to round itself off, then it’s not a Planemo, then it’s not a World.

        Maximum gravity probably also solves itself, because surface gravity scales only slowly with mass. An object would likely become a gas giant long before humans couldn’t walk on the surface. (Jupiter’s “surface” gravity is only 2.5g even though it has 300 times the mass of Earth.)

        Double Earth’s mass and you only increase surface gravity to 1.2g. Double Earth’s mass, but with Mars’ density, the surface gravity would still be 1g!

  11. Arguments over nomenclature are best suited for clerks and bureaucrats. The rest of us ought to find more important things to lose sleep over.

  12. The formal definition of “planet” makes no logical sense. That’s what the IAU debate is all about. I’m not sure why people struggle to get this. There is an argument over how to define “planet” in a useful/meaningful way.

    Clearly an orbital definition of “moon” is adequate. A moon is any natural satellite of a non-celestial body. Whether the primary is an asteroid, planet, KBO, or another moon.

    [Which mean both your and JonathonN3’s own definition, “”Moon” tells you a body is orbiting a “planet””, “Moons orbit Planets.”, are wrong.]

    But a purely orbital definition is clearly inadequate for “planet”. Saying “planets orbit stars” isn’t enough, because things orbit stars which we don’t want to call “planets”. (Asteroids, comets…)

    You need a definition that involves the physical properties of the object itself, not just it’s orbit. And the IAU recently added a property of the surrounding space (“has cleared its orbit”). It’s clumsy, an object’s class changes because of the presence or absence of another object. The IAU definition even restricts “planets” to our sun. All exo-planets aren’t “planets”. According to the IAU, there are eight planets in the entire universe.

    “Star” doesn’t work that way. Stars can orbit other stars, either much larger stars or similar sized. They can orbit galaxies alone or in clusters, or can be spat into intergalactic space. It’s their own properties that define them, not their location.

    So why should an object stop being a planet if it doesn’t orbit a star? If an Earthlike or Jupiter-like body was discovered in free-space, would people not still call it a planet?

    So critics of the IAU’s weird mixed properties definition say that “planet” should instead by defined solely by the properties of the object itself, regardless of where it is or what is around it. If you’re already including the properties of the object in the definition of “planet”… why not get rid of the rest of the junk?

    That would mean a planet can be a large moon, can be a double-planet, can orbit a star or can fly free in space. Its classification doesn’t change because it’s captured into orbit (Triton), or because we discover other objects nearby (Pluto).

    In other words, “moon” is a word to describe the orbit of an object regardless of its properties. “Planet” is a word they want to describe the properties of the object regardless of its orbit. Understand?

  13. This is all about overactive egos on the part of a small group of planetary scientists and astronomers. That’s all.

  14. This is not a NASA thing, it is a New Horizon thing. Stern has been beating this dead horse since the re-categorization of Pluto by the IAU in 2006.

    Exactly the same logic applied to the asteroids in 1800 ff, and if it had prevailed, we’d have over 100,000 “planets” by now, instead of eight. Lumping the eight together is far more useful than admitting Pluto, Titan, or the >1000 KPOs lurking out there.

    I can forgive him, he’s invested in Pluto, but he should really come to his senses.

  15. If you accept the IAU definition, you don’t have a common word for planetary-like objects that orbit other stars, since “planet” is restricted to the Sun. That is, according to IAU there are just 8 “planets” in the entire universe. We’d be telling the visitors from Andromeda that their galaxy, and their home system, doesn’t have any planets. So we still wouldn’t have a generic word for objects like Jupiter.

    BTW, for the record, the proposal to widen the definition of “planet” to any non-celestial object in approximate hydrostatic equilibrium (not-star, round), includes the idea of creating various (overlapping) sub-categories. “Gas giants”, “super-Jupiters”, “terrestrial/rocky”, “solar-” versus “exo-” planets, “KBOs”, “major moons”, “major asteroids”, and even “traditional planets” which would be The Nine. The idea being that groups can create ad-hoc classifications that suit their own purposes, while the IAU adopts the broadest possible super-categories.

  16. How about this? All planets have to be bigger than Texas?
    Kids can handle lots of planets. It’s the adults who have problems.

Comments are closed.