Biologist, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA Space Biologist and Payload integrator, Editor of NASAWatch.com and Astrobiology.com, Lapsed climber, Explorer, Synaesthete, Former Challenger Center board member 🖖🏻

22 replies on “Not Everyone Wants To Be The Martian”

  1. Have to completely agree with you Keith. This is fantastic news for both robotic and human space exploration but some people are just sour about everything.

    I bet Emily would have a conniption fit if it was decided that we could no longer land robots on Mars because of the risk of contamination.

    The fact is we should investigate stuff like this, not run away in fear of contamination. Sterilize as best you can to be sure but we will never reach 100%. Heck, you could argue that Mars is already contaminated by all the landers we have sent there.

    1. If we land reasonably sterilized rovers and don’t find anything within 15-20 meters of the surface that might be life in a proposed human landing area, it’s probably fine to send humans in my opinion. You could just write off anything that comes up right on the surface as contamination unless proven otherwise, and focus on deep-below-surface potential life (send the drill separately and have it sterilized beforehand so humans never come in direct contact with most of the drilling part, or have some way to sterilize the drill head).

  2. Classic Planetary Society bilge. That Special Regions garbage is tying our hands behind our back. After all aren’t we looking for life on Mars? These Special Regions (RSLs, gullies, near surface ground ice) which are the best sites are off limits for exploration by man or machine now how stupid is that?!

    1. The trick is pretend there is life on Mars and that we have to spend big bucks to keep hunting for it.

      If NASA proves there is or is not life on Mars then how would they justify any funding?

      It is largely a scam

      1. Whether or not there is life on Mars, it would still be worth exploring.

        If someone did conclusively demonstrate that there isn’t life on Mars, I think that would actually open it up to human exploration, since it wouldn’t matter if it were contaminated with Earth life.

          1. I’m not. Let’s be honest here – Mars isn’t some type of final frontier or New World. It’s Antarctica without the breathable air. There’s no real reason to actually bother trying to put a settlement there.

          2. Antarctica currently has a permanent population of about 1000 (well, the total is constant, although “permanent” might not be the right word, since it isn’t the same people year-after-year. That’s just the total who winter over, or the minimum population.)

          3. True, and there would probably be more people down there if they ever changed the treaty to allow commercial extraction of resources from the continent. But they don’t really form a permanent settlement there – they come home after work.

            I think it would be the same thing with any Mars or off-world base. Faster and cheaper space travel would only make that easier, too.

          4. I said “permanent” might not be the best term for the Antarctic population, but “come home after work” isn’t either. The people who winter over are down there for about six months, and some longer. Even (or especially) when the trip took over a month by boat, long stays were common. My father spent two and a half years down there in 1957-1559. That sort of duration isn’t too far off what a Mars base might involve.

          5. Exactly my sense. Existing technology struggles with any sort of deep gravity well. Why not develop precursor deep-space habitation first? In situ development of asteroid metals (mining, smelting, forming), methods of creating spin-gravity, space tugs, re-fueling tech- lots of things needed to live in space and all much more affordable than a Mars landing.

          6. It probably is. I think the better options for life are Europa or Titian. But Mars is easier to reach and study.

    2. They aren’t off limits, and I don’t know anyone who is suggesting they should be. We can send a lander or rover there, it just needs to be sterilized per COSPAR Level IVc requirements – “the entire landed system must be sterilized to a surface biological burden level of ≤ 30 spores [“spores” being “aerobic microorganisms that survive a heat shock of 80°C for 15 minutes”] and a total (surface, mated, and encapsulated) bioburden level of ≤ 30 + (2 x 10^5) spores.”

      https://cosparhq.cnes.fr/si…

        1. It’s already been/being done. I had to go through this with MSL and PP will be practiced for Mars 2020. Emily, the “planetary evangelist”, doesn’t seem to be know this.

      1. Some food for thought regarding the costs of planetary protection: The overprotection of Mars, Alberto G. Fairén & Dirk Schulze-Makuch, Nature Geoscience 6,
        510–511(2013) doi:10.1038/ngeo1866
        Published online 27 June 2013

        1. I don’t think the answer is to say that no planetary protection guidelines are needed.

      2. If that’s going to be the guidance for decades, then it might actually be worth the significant expense to do a sample return of decent size – with part of it being replicated to simulate exposing bacterial spores to Martian conditions. If we could determine for sure whether Martian surface conditions are implacably hostile to potential life from Earth, it’d be a big help for future mission design.

        1. Of course, there are also planetary protection requirements for back-contamination. If you are returning samples from a site where you actually expect extraterrestrial live (or consider it possible), then returning a sample to Earth has its own problems.

        2. I’m not sure what you mean by “implacably hostile,” but we do have a lot of data about conditions on the Martian surface. There are even labs that recreate those conditions for experimentation here on Earth.

          http://www.techtimes.com/ar…

  3. I just thought of something, which is probably wrong, but still. Any microbes that survive a spacecraft clean room are going to be some incredibly hardy, tough creatures – exactly the wrong type of creatures to be carrying to Mars. But that type of hardiness almost always comes with a fitness cost, such that they get out-competed back on Earth in regular niches by more vulnerable bacteria.

    So . . . what if you made minimal efforts to avoid biological contamination before sending a probe over? Wouldn’t the fragile bacteria displace any potential hardy free-riders, then get destroyed both by space radiation, entry into the atmosphere, and planetary conditions?

  4. There is a lot of surprising comic relief in this movie, mostly from Michael Pena’s character, who did the same thing when he was in ‘Ant-Man’ (2015). I was surprised as to how little screen time Jessica Chastain had throughout this movie, but this is Matt Damon’s movie, and spending just over two hours with him is good enough.

Comments are closed.