Well @SpaceX landed a used rocket ship in Florida again. #Boring #CRS9 pic.twitter.com/7c2lWkgDWy
— NASA Watch (@NASAWatch) July 18, 2016
This is not a NASA Website. You might learn something. It's YOUR space agency. Get involved. Take it back. Make it work—for YOU.
Well @SpaceX landed a used rocket ship in Florida again. #Boring #CRS9 pic.twitter.com/7c2lWkgDWy
— NASA Watch (@NASAWatch) July 18, 2016
Biologist, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA Space Biologist and Payload integrator, Editor of NASAWatch.com and Astrobiology.com, Lapsed climber, Explorer, Synaesthete, Former Challenger Center board member 🖖🏻
More by Keith CowingComments are closed.
NASA Watch: Your support is needed, support independent journalism.
Thank you for whatever support you can provide. We recently launched this upgraded website which will allow us to expand our coverage. But the design and hosting come at cost, as does adding new services. We're also going looking to add new journalists as we expand.
We'll send a verification code to %EMAIL%.
Congrats, SpaceX! The access to space “new world order” is here.
What a dramatic launch and landing. Night launches are always spectacular and both of the RTLS landings have been at night.
When will SpaceX do a RTLS landing during daylight?
The whole event reminded me of something out of Star Wars.
Launch windows and times depend on orbital mechanics, and there are other constraints such as Sun angle, ISS position etc. Sooner or later one will synch up.
The Iridium NEXT launches out of Vandenberg should be RTLS, however it is not soon enough to know if they’ll be daytime launches, but those are the next opportunities. For Cape Canaveral, the next RTLS opportunities are CRS-10 and -11.
Congrats to SpaceX on a successful launch and first stage landing! I watched this live on the technical stream. Looked really impressive at night. You could see the different burns as they were called.
I loved the addition of the view from the ground during the supersonic retropropulsion phase. It’s remarkable how brief that burn is.
Saw the separation and then the 2nd and third burns from east of A1A in the port. Quite taken by how little time as that first stage came (hurtling) down, can’t imagine calling that boring 😉
Then of course was the boom…
–
Until they actually reuse one of these landed boosters, it’s just a novelty. They’re running out of room to store them all at KSC.
So the Saturn I, IB, & V launches before Apollo 8 (or even 11) were just novelties?
Glass half empty, is it?
No, that’s an apples to oranges comparison. Those launches tested capabilities used on future missions. So far there hasn’t been a future mission for a landed Falcon 9 booster. Nobody knows yet if it will be economically feasible to reuse a booster as opposed to building a new one, OR if anyone will be willing to risk their payload on a refurbished booster.
“Old Space” dogma.
This September or October they will launch a used booster. They may or may not succeed, but Space X has proven that it will learn and be back. Space X also has an impressive record of doing new activities and eventually succeeding that NASA and other aerospace companies do not.
Instead of “novelty”, I’d call it an extended period of data collection and data verification. Statistically the uncertainty in their data and conclusions should be getting smaller as the number of Stage 1 landings increase. If I were the boss, I’d rather have more data and better confidence in the scientific or engineering conclusions than lose a mission because we didn’t collect enough data.
I wonder if the sonic boom from the returning stage with its widespread disturbance will be a source of future problems, hindering the use of the landing zones? I sure hope not.
http://www.wesh.com/news/sp…
Shuttles did that, but they were far apart.
It was not any louder than the Shuttle but may be heard in a different area. Watching the booster descend straight toward us during the entry burn was a spectacular sight.
We heard the booms regularly here in Naples when the shuttle approached the Cape from the southwest, but when they approached from the northwest conditions usually disallowed hearing it here.
I listened for it Monday night, but without much success.
They’ll need better timing. At 1am they woke up a lot of people :p
I thought of that also after reading about the sonic booms. Concorde comes to mind, and the restrictions that it eventually ran into. Some might argue that anyone who moves within earshot of a rocket launch facility should expect occasional “loud noises”, but that rationale doesn’t fully work for airports either when flight frequency increases, requiring a certain amount of compromise with the local communities such as curfews and noise abatement procedures. Assuming that SpaceX recovery frequency increases, and especially if the economics prove out as expected leading other launch providers to develop similar methods, it’s possible there could be some restrictions imposed in the future.
That being said, I heard several Shuttle booms at Edwards, and while loud, it wasn’t the window rattling, heartbeat-skipping booms that I remember occasionally hearing living near the coast in Orange County, California in the 1960’s when military jets doing offshore training runs sometimes got a little too close to shore. Later restrictions kept them much farther away and we didn’t hear sonic booms anymore. Shuttle boom didn’t seem as loud, but I realize that’s subjective, and also variable based on a lot of other factors such as proximity, altitude, and weather.
Agreed I hope it doesn’t become a problem, but I would think probably curfews would be the primary restriction, which although inconvenient as they would have to skip otherwise viable launch windows, it would not be insurmountable
We heard them quite loudly when passing directly overhead, but had to be looking for them, usually going outside. Hard to hear indoors.
As to restrictions, the space coast is likely to welcome the activity.
No restrictions required! Please. It’s not like windows are breaking. Shuttle booms were loud BOOMS, with a deeper tone and they would rattle windows and such. The two SX booms (so far) sounded to me like someone shot a high powered rifle, two shots in quick succession. Why is that? My guess is that Shuttle was a “fat bodied” and extremely heavy airplane. The F9 booster is long and skinny, plus it weighs practically nothing. F9 drops through the air, leading with 9 engine nozzles and landing legs tucked under. We are just beginning to learn this new phenomenon. I plan on witnessing every single one as they come, from as close as I can, with my binoculars. Daytime RTLS will be very interesting, especially when they happen late afternoon with low sun light to help the cameras and spectators.
SpaceX is getting so much better. There are new challenges to overcome, new obstacles to navigate, and the usual suspects on the hill. However, nothing is impossible and frankly, what worked a few short years ago will not work now.
We have this – we just need to keep the politicians as far away as possible.
I notice that the capsule is berthed, not docked – the CanadaArm grabs it ; recalling a discussion about these alternatives here a week or so ago, I wondered why berthing would ever be chosen over docking? Assuming that docking is safe and automatic- a stretch, but on the horizon- wouldn’t it be a better choice every time?
Also: where exactly is crazy town, anyway? 🙂
I think maybe NASA has nightmares of a Dragon – ISS version of that little Progress – Mir “Oops-ski”, even though that wasn’t a truly autonomous-caused event. I bet that NASA is just a little paranoid over the remote possibility of an unmanned American COMMERCIAL (read: not invented by NASA) spacecraft so much as smudging the paint, let alone crashing off inhabited modules and through solar arrays, of a $100B facility. I can understand this for first-time flights of unknown (non-NASA) craft and its (non-NASA) operators, but even after several successful missions, it must still be hard for them to move away from that paradigm.
Also: I think crazy town is a little due east of Lala-Land. 8-P
The CBM (Common Berthing Mechanism) has a hatch that is larger and square with rounded corners, 1.27m across, so entire ISS payload racks can fit through it. The IDSS (International Docking System Standard) docking hatches are round and smaller, 0.80m in diameter, and the docking mechanism petals further obstruct the passage, so ISS payload racks can’t fit through them.
Docking requires more sophisticated control systems on-board the approaching spacecraft. Berthing requires it to hold still while the ‘dynamic’ systems are on-board the receiving vehicle/port; docking requires the arriving vehicle to ‘hold still’ in attitude while it actively manages translation control in three axes.
Sure, the difference is clear even to non-engineers like me; the question is why berthing is used? As far as I know the capsule is capable of docking?
The current cargo dragon capsule is not capable of docking. The CBM ports do not have the tracking equipment and range finders needed for docking.
Well, duh. Shoulda known something as obvious as that.
What Doug said. It was less of a technical challenge (and thus cheaper; it doesn’t have to be as robust structurally, either) to build a spacecraft that did not have to be able to actively dock.
Another factor, of which I honestly do not know, might have been a philosophical one: NASA, perhaps choosing on the side of caution, may have preferred to be ‘in charge’ (i.e., the ISS in control) during such a critical and dangerous phase with these ‘untested’ newcomers. Now that they have proven (and are still proving) themselves, NASA is likely more comfortable with them designing, building, & operating their crewed systems near the ISS and her crew. Just a thought.
This is exciting! It looks from this article that Space X is planning on recovering 3 at once from the Falcon Heavy scheduled to be launched later this year which – win or lose – will be spectacular. http://www.theverge.com/201…
Likely two will be RTLS and one will be landing on the Autonomous Drone Ship.