Amit Kshatriya
Amit Kshatriya

Keith’s note: The following was sent to all NASA employees today by Associate Administrator Amit Kshatriya: NASA Team Members, It wasn’t until this August at Ames that I personally administered the civil servant’s oath of service. I felt privileged to have that experience for the first time in front of 180 new civil servants sitting inside the country’s largest wind tunnel. It was a very NASA thing to do, and reminded me of the incredible ambition of those who served before us. Those 180 folks had already spent years, maybe even decades, contributing to the NASA mission, and for many, their service did not begin that day. Still, there is something profound about standing before your fellow Americans and freely accepting an obligation to the Constitution of the United States. It is a reminder that service is not principally about what we are entitled to receive, but rather about what we are willing to give to a cause larger than ourselves. The obligations that derive from the oath have led us, among other things, to launch an effort called NASA Builds, which is the principal content of this note.

There is something that still stirs in me when I say those words and how they renew my spirit. We promise to support and defend the Constitution, to bear true faith and allegiance to it, and to well and faithfully discharge the duties entrusted to us. It is not an oath to a program, a schedule, level of complexity, or a particular result. Rather it is a commitment to the American people and to the faithful stewardship of the trust they have placed in us. Importantly, it is as true if it is your first day on the job or your 10 thousandth day. Every day, we’re called to approach our work as if it matters deeply, because it does, while also recognizing that the mission will continue beyond any one individual. That balance is at the heart of civil service. We are temporary stewards of enduring responsibilities, united by a commitment to something greater than ourselves. The authority, influence, and impact we exercise do not come from ourselves, but flow from the majesty and grandeur of the people of the United States. Keeping that perspective grounds us in our purpose and reminds us that we serve not only the mission, but the American people who entrust us with it. We must never forget that.

Throughout the history of NASA, this country has asked us to do things that we did not yet know how to do – if we could organize ourselves in a way to build things that were considered to be impossible. NASA has always accepted this assignment. We assembled the people, built the tools to build the machines, then built the machines, confronted all the problems, and figured it out. We learned from our successes and failures, sometimes at the ultimate consequence, and turned extraordinary ambitions into machines that fulfilled them.

We see that inheritance in the missions that Administrator Isaacman so eloquently enumerated last weekend in his message to the agency. These achievements are diverse, but they rest on the same foundation: skilled people, capable institutions, and the discipline and courage to make near-impossible things work.

Administrator Isaacman has also set a clear and demanding course for the institution that NASA can become – to build up the technical strength that our missions demand, to bring critical skills back into the agency, to assert our rights over our own productive capacity and designs, in short, to return our agency’s ability to build. American leadership in science, technology, and exploration is not guaranteed by what we accomplished in years past. We have to earn it every day, including today.

I am writing this from the Langley Research Center in Virigina. In 1958, when the country decided to put an American in orbit, a small team of government engineers at Langley, the Space Task Group, designed the Mercury spacecraft and built and tested its early boilerplate capsules themselves. Because they had done the work with their own hands, they knew how to be a demanding and capable customer when industry built the flight vehicles. To lead the work of doing near-impossible missions, we have to know how to do that work ourselves.

Today, we launch NASA Builds, an agencywide effort to strengthen NASA as one integrated production enterprise. NASA Builds is how our centers will carry out the Administrator’s direction to rebuild our in-house technical strength.

Across our 10 centers, we have extraordinary people, specialized facilities, tooling, and knowledge developed over generations. But too often, boundaries between our organizations become barriers to our work. Expertise at one center can be difficult to connect with a mission need at another. Maybe incompatible tools, work instructions, technical processes, and standards create friction that we cannot afford. Some of these differences are necessary, and others have simply accumulated over time. We have an obligation to distinguish between them and take action.

NASA Builds will begin with center-led Pathfinders that address real mission needs while identifying obstacles we will remove as one enterprise. They will produce useful hardware, software, scientific instruments, test capabilities, and other mission enabling products. They will also give our people opportunities to develop the judgement that comes from designing, building, testing, qualifying, and operating those same things, providing the scars and learning that comes from taking flight hardware, software, production tooling, ground support equipment, and test support equipment through their full lifecycle. The end-to-end nature of these efforts is critical – too often we have done in-house work only up to a certain degree of completion, due to limitation of resources. These efforts are useful but the learning we are trying to drive out comes from the choices that have to be made to converge on a final product. The challenge of defining Pathfinders according to these constraints has already been given to the mission directorate, center directors, engineering directors, and other OICs, and we will take submissions this week.

A few clarifying points. Our first responsibility remains the missions already entrusted to us. Urgent program needs will have priority for our in-house capabilities, and the Pathfinders will proceed within available resources and authorities, including how they are funded consistent with our appropriations. NASA Builds must strengthen mission execution, not compete with it. If a Pathfinder starts drawing people or facilities away from immediate program requirements, we will adjust the Pathfinder.

This work will be shepherded by partners at NASA Headquarters, but owned by the mission directors and executed by our center directors. I think this is a very important thing to hear. We are not establishing another HQ production organization or creating new layers of approval between capable people and their work. Our centers possess the expertise, facilities, and experience on which NASA depends. They must have the responsibility and authority to put those capabilities to use. HQ has a different obligation – to set clear objectives, connect the enterprise, remove obstacles that individual centers cannot resolve, support common practices, and ensure that what one part of NASA learns becomes available to the next.

To that end, I have asked Christina Koch, who is now acting as the deputy Chief Engineer for NASA, to lead this effort on my behalf. I think her record speaks for itself, but suffice to say she understands both the work of making difficult systems function and the responsibility of trusting those systems when there can be ultimate consequences. She will work directly with our center directors, mission directors, and technical communities to get the Pathfinders underway and carry their lessons across NASA. I will remain accountable for the agency-level decisions and support necessary for their success.

An essential dimension of the NASA Builds effort is not just the products themselves, but the modernization of the technical foundation that enables their development. Said more plainly, it is not just about the What, but about the How, and one of the key figures of merit of the first round of Pathfinders will be how deliberately their scope seeks out the impediments to action. Working collaboratively with all responsible tech authorities, we will improve the standards, tools, and processes that connect requirements to design, development, test, and evaluation of these products. It is essential that if we are building as one NASA then we have common standards and processes to enable to free flow of physical and human capital across the production enterprise. Every change to these standards, importantly, will receive the same review and concurrence as it would today, and I have commitment from the Safety and Mission Assurance and Health and Medical Technical Authority that they are in full support of the standards modernization.

This is the work of the entire agency. Our engineers, scientists, researchers, technicians, flight controllers, and operators cannot succeed without contracting and acquisition professionals, financial managers, logisticians, human resources specialists, IT and cybersecurity professionals, facilities personnel, and countless others that make the mission possible. Every discipline has something to contribute and is essential to our success.

I know many of you have good reason to be skeptical. You and your families have made sacrifices that don’t appear on a program schedule, and many of you have carried this agency through years of uncertainty while continuing to deliver extraordinary results. Many of you still serve this mission as contractor teammates and at JPL, you do not take the federal oath, but you share our devotion with us, and NASA Builds will depend on you too. For all of you, I want you to hear this clearly: NASA Builds is not a repudiation of our work or the people that came before us. It is an obligation to preserve and strengthen what we have already built, and to make sure that the people who follow have the opportunities and capabilities they will need to conduct the next generation of impossible missions.

It is also an obligation to take care of our teammates. It means sharing what we know instead of guarding it, helping a colleague solve a problem even when it is not ours to solve, respecting the time and effort of those who depend on our decisions, and speaking honestly when something is wrong. This burden primarily falls on the members of NASA’s senior leadership team. Leaders must provide clear priorities, adequate support, and the authority needed to act. They also need to be willing to hear uncomfortable facts and to stand behind the people who bring them forward.

The Administrator has spoken clearly about extreme ownership. To me, this means knowing who is responsible for a problem, having the courage to make a decision, and accepting accountability for the result. Our commitment to extreme ownership must be matched by a clear standard of professional conduct, especially as we endeavor to challenge some commonly held notions that might be obsolete in the times we live in. Disagreeing about whether a requirement applies is not obstruction – all concerns will be heard and resolved on evidence. To be plain, we will not allow personal ambition, organizational pride, or the protection of parochial interests to take precedence over the reality of our mission responsibilities. We cannot tolerate the deliberate withholding of expertise, the shifting of responsibility to avoid difficult decisions, or the use of process to obstruct authorized work for a non-mission related advantage. Your duty requires you to both have the courage to challenge a decision and the discipline to champion decisions once properly made. Our commercial, academic, and international partners remain indispensable. Strengthening NASA’s own capabilities will make us better technical authorities, more effective customers, stronger partners, and a viable relief valve when the production of our partners cannot meet the mission need.

The measure of our service will not be the number of initiatives we launch or the speeches we give. It will be the missions we deliver and the institution we leave behind. Someday, the people now entering NASA will be the experienced hands passing their knowledge to another generation. They will inherit the facilities we maintain, the standards we establish, the capabilities we preserve, and the habits of leadership we practice today. They will also inherit the consequences of the decisions we fail to make. When that day comes, I want them to be able to say that we met the obligations of our time, that we faced difficult problems without turning on one another, that we respected what our predecessors gave us, took care of our people, and left NASA stronger than we found it.

Oaths, we have taken. Now, we fulfill them all.

Amit Kshatriya NASA Associate Administrator

Biologist, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA Space Biologist and Payload integrator, Editor of NASAWatch.com and Astrobiology.com, Lapsed climber, Explorer, Synaesthete, Former Challenger Center board member 🖖🏻

Leave a comment