Biologist, Explorers Club Fellow, ex-NASA Space Biologist and Payload integrator, Editor of NASAWatch.com and Astrobiology.com, Lapsed climber, Explorer, Synaesthete, Former Challenger Center board member 🖖🏻

30 replies on “Those Times The President Said The Moon/Mars Phrase”

  1. Keith Cowing nails it again! Good quick accurate summary of where we have been on getting humans out of low earth orbit since 1973.

  2. Because by the time the bureaucrats at NASA finally got around to putting a plan together the Democrats got into office and sent NASA in a different direction.?

      1. No, the Republicans are trying to return NASA is to the pathway it was on after the Columbia accident, (VSE) first the Moon, then Mars. It was President Obama that created the dead end detour to ARM and SLS that NASA must backtrack on to return to the main pathway again.

          1. Remember Senator Shelby was a Democrat before the Republicans won the Senate, then switched parties the next day to keep his political power. So really his one and only loyalty is to Huntsville. ?

        1. Richard Shelby and Kay Bailey Hutchison were major factors – one saved SLS jobs and one saved Orion jobs.

          1. You are confusing tactics with strategy. Senator Shelby doesn’t care what is launched on the SLS as long as their are jobs in Huntsville. Similarly Senator Hutchison didn’t care about the purpose of the Orion as long as the pork kept flowing. The Orion, if you recall, was originally going to take astronauts to the ISS on the Ares I. When President Obama killed it the Orion survived as an ISS lifeboat. Then it moved to the SLS to send crew on the ARM, when the ARM ended it became the taxi to the Gateway. The strategic goals change, but the pork keeps flowing.

          2. And the reason we don’t go anywhere is the pork. Until the pork to SLS/Orion stops, NASA simply won’t have the budget to actually land anywhere.

          3. Which is exactly why the cutting edge of space technology has shifted to commercial firms like SpaceX.

        2. Republicans: “Let’s first pass a tax rebate costing trillions of dollars (with a disproportionate amount going to the top 20% of the people in this country: https://tinyurl.com/y7q5m7rl), blow a hole in the budget, send the debt sky high, then talk about putting together a NASA budget to send people to the Moon, then Mars.” Sounds like a reasonable, sensible approach to me….

        3. You’re going to have to do more work to convince me, a fellow taxpayer, that going down the gravity well of the moon (even if only as far as lunar orbit) makes more sense that constructing Mars-bound spacecraft in earth orbit, and then sending them directly there.

          There may be a business plan to be argued over whether extraction industries on the moon are ever likely to break even or produce a profit/ Those are, presumably, the arguments that private sector entrepreneurs will use to raise VC funding. But I cannot understand why the American (or any other) taxpayer should foot the bill for business. Exploration, on the other hand….

          Guess I find myself agreeing with Mr. Collins.

          1. I agree and I have long argued that the exploration and development of the Moon should be turned over to a public-private partnership, the Lunar Development Corporation, based/inspired on the success of Comsat had achieving President Kennedy’s second space goal of a global satellite communication system. But bureaucrats at NASA will likely fight such a move in terms of a lunar return. So we have Lucy and the football as Administrations change and change NASA goal.

  3. It’s why it’s always important to take these Space Pronouncements with skepticism, asking where the funding is. If they don’t get out there pushing quickly for a funding bill for NASA on it, then they’re not serious and it’s just talk until they switch to another issue they truly care about.

    At least Bridenstine seems pretty serious on this, and is probably struggling hard on how to sell the needed budget hike.

  4. My usual gripe: Not surprising since they always put Mars in the sentence when talking about the moon. It will cost a lot put someone on the moon, it will cost unimaginable to put someone on Mars. That unimaginable estimate leads to a non-starter when trying to expand beyond LEO.

  5. NASA does a wonderful job talking about the past, creating feelings of nostalgia and pride. Just look a the halls of any NASA buildings; wonderful pictures of the past.

    The skill set that is needed is creating possibility of an inspiring future, in the face of skepticism, cynicism, and no possibility about the future..

  6. By the time the “gubmint” gets around to actually putting up Gateway, getting SLS/Orion operational…if ever…private enterprise will be on the Moon, with base(s) established with men and women! Or, the Chinese will!

    1. Elon Musk has already done a tweet to the effect that the simplest way to convince NASA that Starship could take astronauts to the Moon is by landing the Starship with astronauts on the Moon. But I am more cynical and believe that NASA will still find reasons to say Starship is not suitable for transporting NASA astronauts to the Moon. Never underestimate the stubbornness of a bureaucrat. Pigs is Pigs as the old story goes. ?

      1. NASA may very well say that Starship “isn’t suitable for transporting NASA astronauts to the Moon.” But, unless they can find some legal mumbo-jumbo, the only clearance for private citizens or SpaceX employees will need to come from the FAA…if, indeed they have the authority to prevent it. (I’m no space lawyer…don’t even play one on T.V.!) But, suppose the FAA were to grant a flight certification for LEO, and SpaceX transports its own people there, and rendezvous with the Starship. FAA might not have jurisdiction beyond there. Depending on who one refers to as a porcine individual, maybe, “Some pigs is more equal than other pigs!” And some pig’s lawyers may be more equal than NASA’s or the FAA!

        1. FAA may not have the jurisdiction, but the U.S. does have legal responsibility as per Article VI of the OST. That is why one of the focuses of the National Space Council has been to update and revise the federal regulatory environment for space commerce firms.

          1. All too true. My point was that even if NASA was unwilling to fly its astronauts on commercial spacecraft, those outfits could, pending FAA approval, fly non-NASA people.

        2. It’s amazing what a creative lawyer or bureaucrat can come up with. I’d have to check on the details, but the FAA has quite a bit of authority over aircraft flying outside the United States. If the company is based in the US, or if the aircraft is operated from a US airport, FAA regulations apply. For example, a United Airlines aircraft, flying from Houston to Mexico City to Panama City and then back to Houston, still has to follow FAA regulations on the Mexico City to Panama City leg.

          Also, you’re talking about the current laws. The FAA and its predecessors didn’t exist until 1926. Even if the FAA currently doesn’t have any charter to regulate passenger safety on spacecraft, that could change. All it could take was a well-publicized accident and an act of Congress.

  7. “Lucy” … love it !

    simple, clear, everyone (who’s seen “Peanuts”) understands it.

      1. “lucy football” is enough to get google hits, youtube hits, and i’m sure hits on whatever the kids use today.

  8. Note that Democrats started Apollo, Nixon cancelled it. I think republicans would prefer tax cuts to lunar expeditions, and democrats would prefer health care.

  9. We keep not going to the Moon because there is simply no political or popular support for doing so at the funding levels it would cost – as one president after another discovers the hard way.

    So we are left with only sandbox for aerospace contractors and their favorite congresspeople to play in, until someone can come along and dramatically lower the cost of going to these places with people.

Comments are closed.