People Listen To Tony Stark - Not To Space Advocates

Government and Space: Lead, Follow, and Get Out of the Way, Rick Tumlinson, Huffington Post

"2012 will see those committed to settling space (O'Neillians) begin orbital delivery operations, private microgravity experiments on the space station, and sub-orbital, commercial, human space-flight tests. Recently, the revolution jumped another level, as a commercial space-station company announced it is partnering with a commercial spaceflight firm, thus completely eliminating the government from the equation. And yet, even as some of today's savviest and wealthiest business leaders begin to dive into this new ocean of possibility, many of yesterday's space heroes, our government and political class, don't get it. The irony should not be lost that this same year, a presidential candidate got laughed off the campaign stage for suggesting a human colony on the Moon -- just days before a group of American entrepreneurs worth tens of billions of dollars announced plans to mine asteroids."

Keith's note: Not to single you out, Rick, but people are out of work. They do not want moon bases or asteroid mines, they want jobs. And people do not really get to worried about whether or not the government is involved in things or not. They do not really waste a whole lot of time on the "D" or "R". They just want whatever is broken to be fixed i.e. they want results. They are going to vote for the politicians who they think will accomplish that task. The fact that the current Democratic Administration is pro-space business and Congressional Republicans are often adamantly opposed to the support of space commerce by NASA just confuses this discussion further.

Space cadets unite! Otherwise we're irrelevant, Jim Banke, Orbital Inclinations

"While I often bristle at Cowing's blunt style, I completely agree with the substance of his response to The Moon Society's president. And believe me, I wish it weren't the case because actually moving the needle on space policy is really the key challenge we face in the space advocacy community. We have yet to find a way to turn all that outstanding public outreach into viable political currency such that every Senator, every member of the House of Representatives, and each occupant of the White House - no matter what party they represent - will support a robust national space policy."

So long as space activists continue to only talk to/at one another - recycling the same semi-obscure jargon ("O'Neillians"?) and tired memes (Moon bases) - and not present their viewpoints in a fashion that is actually relevant to the work-a-day lives of the public as a whole - none of this will ever happen. After 30-40 years, you'd think that space activists would have figured this out by now. I attended back-to-back AIAA and NSS meetings last week in Washington, DC and saw no evidence that anyone in the space world has gotten the message.

Curiously, while space folks were engaging in choir practice, the media - and regular folks working 9 to 5 jobs - seemed to think that Dragon's flight was cool and newsworthy. Why were all of the space activists and industry types so totally unable to capitalize on such a overt media opportunity and reach out to the remaining 99.99% of the population?

Face it: no one outside of these space conclaves is listening to space advocates. And when people do listen to laid-back Elon in his t-shirt talking about his excellent spaceship, they do not make the connection to space advocates or the stiff NASA suits - except to note that they aren't the one with the cool rocketship - the one that does what NASA can't do. No one connects with Wernher von Braun any more - but they do connect to Tony Stark, it would seem.

"Marvel's The Avengers" To Screen for Crew of International Space Station

"Marvel Studios announced today that they arranged with NASA to transfer their record-breaking blockbuster film "Marvel's The Avengers" to NASA's Mission Control in Houston, which will uplink the film to the International Space Station (ISS), currently orbiting 220 miles above Earth. The film will then be screened for the space station crew's exclusive enjoyment."

Keith's note: What a waste of bandwidth. They could have sent a DVD up in Dragon ;-)

  • submit to reddit


Sword and Planet by Christopher Ruocchio - Baen Books
Agent of the Imperium by Marc Miller - Baen Books

Join our mailing list

Commercialization: Monthly Archives

Monthly Archives

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Keith Cowing published on June 3, 2012 7:40 PM.

New Issue: Space Quarterly Magazine was the previous entry in this blog.

Jed Pearson is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.