Clarifying NASA’s Warp Drive Program
“Few people know this but NASA actually has a warp drive program underway at Johnson Space Center. A recent article on the program created some open-ended questions that needed to be answered. The article seemed to imply that Harold White (who heads the project) had signed non-disclosure agreements such that he could not discuss public-funded research. That’s a little unusual for NASA. So I sent a series of questions to Harold White and NASA PAO.”
NASA’s Super Secret Warp Drive Program, earlier post
NASA Warp Drive Update
Comments are closed.

JBIS is a cool place to discuss new spaceflight ideas, but it’s not a peer-reviewed journal for spacetime physics.
It is on the Science Citation Index though. Nothing to be ashamed of.
For its field. But it would be good to see at least a Phys. Rev D, for even basic peer review on the issues involved.
And with no peer review required, it’s nothing to be especially proud of.
Having been on the inside, I can tell you that peer review is no holy grail. It’s a lot less effective and unbiased than laymen think. See this article, one of many in professional journals, and consider just who is making this statement.
“If peer review was a drug it would never be allowed onto the market,” says Drummond Rennie, deputy editor of the Journal Of the American Medical Association and intellectual father of the international congresses of peer review that have been held every four years since 1989. “Peer review would not get onto the market because we have no convincing evidence of its benefits but a lot of evidence of its flaws. Yet…almost no scientists know anything about the evidence on peer review.”http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov…
Lay people know even less, yet trust peer review far more than is merited.
Yeah, but having been both on the inside and outside (published and a reviewer), and with a spacetime physics background (and, indeed, worked on exactly some of the issues here), this is an area where a paper can seriously benefit from peer review. It’s pretty easy, in this case, to identify researchers who know enough to produce good input on this. Though you’d want at least somebody with a decent semi-classical quantum gravity background, as one of the big red herrings in this area is the use of the term “negative energy” to mean different things, especially as concerns the use of Hawing & Ellis results and/or assumptions about quantum fields in curved space.
The peer review process certainly has its flaws, but the complete lack of peer review isn’t exactly encouraging.
I think we should give him the benefit of the (very large) doubt. If it shows nothing, it’s $50K down the tubes, probably equal to one second’s wastage on the SLS. If it shows anything scientifically interesting…..
NASA has a history of investigating off-the-wall physics claims. Such as Eugene Podkletnov and his spinning superconductors, or Eric Laithwaite and his gyroscopes. It’s mostly harmless.
Te problem isn’t that it might show nothing. The problem is that there is no indication whether what it shows or does not show will ever be revealed.
Having following this story for a little while, and not being a physicist I think the toughest part is understanding whether this is legit science or not. On one hand I heard White and a collaborator go into length defending on pod cast about why other physicist misinterpret what they are doing. On the other hand there have been established physicist who are on the record stating this has basically no merit.
“On the other hand there have been established
physicist who are on the record stating this has basically no merit.”
But isn’t looking in areas that the establishment doesn’t agree with a part of science? He went through the proper process, his project got
funded, and now he’s trying to prove it. I’d like to see what he can do.
“But isn’t looking in areas that the establishment doesn’t agree with a part of science?”
Looking for data to contradict current theories is part of science. Coming up with new theories that are logically consistent is part of science.
Continuing to press ahead with theories that everyone competent to understand agrees are not logically consistent? No, that’s not part of science. The term for that is pseudo-science.
Yes, I’m sure Copernicus would agree with that.
Seriously, though, like I said, he went through a proper review and he got funded. Actually, I agree that your statement is right 99.9% of the time. But maybe this is .1%
I disagree that the review was proper. I think it was reviewed by some managers at NASA who don’t really know much about modern physics. I don’t think it was reviewed by professional academic physicists who have published in the field.
I also don’t think whoever made the decision to fund this had an open, unbiased call for proposals for basic physics research. There are a lot of real physicists and their grad students at real universities and research labs that could have applied with proposals that actually have some real merit. Just take a look at how Darpa or NSF, for example, choose research to fund.
OK, I’ll agree with that. I don’t know what the review process was.
I do have to ask, though, in the other post you said he that White wasn’t a “real physicist.” Why do you say that? Don’t take me as being argumentative here, I honestly don’t know his background.
My experience is consistent with this. NASA research and development funding boards do their best to pick projects that merit investigation, I am not putting them down. They are probably at least as accurate as decisions made on some far larger programs. But it is not a scientific review.
“I do have to ask, though, in the other post you said he that White wasn’t a “real physicist.””
By “real physicist” I mean someone who publishes research in any of the hundreds of peer-reviewed journals that are widely considered reputable in physics.
In the list of White’s publications given by JSC’s answers to Keith’s questions, only one is in a peer-reviewed physics journal: a paper in General Relativity and Gravitation in 2003. One paper ten years ago does not a physicist make.
Such funding decisions are not subject to scientific review. It is a decision by several people, usually managers or engineers. They try to pick projects that seem to have merit based on the explanation the presenter makes. The system is not perfect, but nothing is. But in this case the task is basic science rather than engineering development, so the level of secrecy and lack of scientific review are puzzling. Scientific peer review itself is often biased and occasionally completely wrong, but it should be part of the process. But the biggest problem is the secrecy. We do not even know exactly what he is trying to prove.
“…not being a physicist I think the toughest part is understanding whether this is legit science or not…established physicist who are on the record stating this has basically no merit.”
I think you’ve already found the answer to your own question.
I think a physicist would consider an experiment to confirm expected relativistic effects of an electric field (if any) reasonable. To say that it was an experiment that would lead to FTL drive would not be credible. Not because FTL is impossible but because the proposed approach does not make it possibe. Here is an interesting discussion of the physics involved, particularly the section at the bottom which discusses why the apparent relative FTL velocties at the limits of the observable universe and the event horizon of a back hole are dfferent from the Alcubierre proposal.
http://physics.stackexchang…
I’ve read the popular science article. This appears to be another case where the popsci author either wasn’t competent enough in relativity to have a meaningful interview or he tried stretching a short conversation into a full article.
Here’s one example: The author said:
“Finally, warp drive poses a conceptual problem. In general relativity, faster-than-light travel is equivalent to moving about in time. In saying that a warp drive is feasible, White is also saying that he can create a time machine.”
In special relativity (flat Minkowskian spacetime) that statement is true, but not in general relativity. General relativity describes the more general case of curved spacetime, where the speed of light depends on the curvature.
One cannot travel faster than light in his own reference frame, but in theory a distorted spacetime region could allow him to travel faster than light in another observer’s reference frame. Alcubierre came up with one such spacetime metric in the 1990’s.
All of the variations on the Alcubierre metric suffer from the need for large amounts of negative energy, which we cannot yet generate (and perhaps never will). No one disputes that, which suggests to me that the popsci author embellished his title for wow factor.
“One cannot travel faster than light in his own reference frame, but in theory a distorted spacetime region could allow him to travel faster than light in another observer’s reference frame.“
This is a key point which so many people seem to ignore (or perhaps don’t know). To the term “distorted spacetime” I would add “or a separate spacetime”. This concept is key to the idea of warp drive, but is not related to the reason why the Alcubierre drive won’t work.
If a space warping device could produce even an acceleration of 0.00001nm/s^2 it would be a huge breakthrough in propulsion. But that wouldn’t get the star trek headline would it. And I strongly suspect – would be just as impossible.
Don’t forget that *every* mass is a space warping device. It warps the space-time around it in an effect we usually call gravity, causing an acceleration.
The trick is not to warp space-time. The trick is to find a way to warp it in a way which can lead to faster-than-light travel.
I’d like NASA to pay me $50k to test the theory that my taking a
vacation in Europe will make me come up with a theory for
faster-than-light travel.
There’s a low chance it will work, but a very
high payoff if it does. By the logic of those defending spending on White’s research, this is a good way to spend NASA money.
Chris,
JSC’s answers to Keith’s questions seem to indicate that the Alcubierre work and the warp drive are separate projects; they’re just both going on at Eagleworks. There’s no indications as to whether one is support research for the other, or they’re completely unrelated. There’s no indication that they’re both currently active. Maybe in the name of protecting IP, one is a smoke screen for the other. There’s obviously more going on here than we’ve been told about, and maybe some deliberate misdirection.
I did find one of JCS’s answers interesting, as follows:
“Is Harold White receiving DARPA or other external funding while working at NASA on his advanced propulsion/warp drive research?
Not at this time.“
Why did they not simply say “No”? Does this mean that DARPA has been in any way involved? If so, there are several possibilities, and it does add a little more credibility to the overall picture. Or, again, maybe the wording is misdirection.
Overall, and given the nature of the beast, I thought JCS’s answers to Keith’s questions were reasonable and even seemingly reasonably complete. It’s more than I was expecting.
I wonder if the answers would have been any different if each of Keith’s questions had said “Eagleworks” instead of “Harold White.”
Steve
I agree that if DARPA were funding it, it would give it far, far, far more credibility. But I don’t see any reason to believe that DARPA has any interest in this. The “Not at this time” answer was to “DARPA or other external funding”. It may just be that White hopes to get other external funding. Or it may be worded this way just to imply that maybe in the future there will be external funding, without having any evidence that will actually happen.
I’m not sure which JSC answers lead you to believe there are separate “Alcubierre” and “warp drive” projects. Can you cite the particular text from the JSC answers that implies that?
Alcubierre is a physicist (a real physicist, unlike White) who proposed a possible warp drive design which now bears his name. So I’m not sure what the distinction between “warp drive” and “Alcubierre” research would be.
I was under the impression that White’s experimental setup was to measure whether he can warp space with some devices he describes as “ring capacitors” or some such. That’s actually only loosely connected to Alcubierre’s warp drive proposal, so maybe the two projects are White’s ring capacitor warping measurement apparatus and his theories relating to Alcubierre’s proposed design.
Chris,
Oops! I screwed up. It was from the PopSci article, which Keith quoted:
“The device looks like a large red velvet doughnut with wires tightly wound around a core, and it’s one of two initiatives Eagleworks is pursuing, along with warp drive. Personally, I have little faith that the PopSci writer really understood much of what he was supposedly told.
I (wrongly, I would now say) combined the above with Keith’s repeated use of the phrase advanced propulsion/warp drive research” and the fact that only one of the papers cited includes any reference to Alcubierre, to read into it that there were two (at least) separate projects going on at Eagleworks. I’m not concluding now that this is necessarily not the case, I’m just admitting that there’s nothing at all conclusive to lead to that conclusion.
As a side note, another thing that bothered me was the paper title, “The Alcubierre Warp Drive in Higher Dimensional Spacetime“. I’m not a physicist any more than White is, but the term “Higher Dimensional” made me pause. There’s no justification that I’m aware of (for whatever little that’s worth) for declaring an ordering or hierarchy to different spacetimes. There are certainly observable “separate” spacetimes, but nothing I’ve ever encountered supports calling one “higher” than another, just separate. This term, as far as I’m concerned, was taken right out of science fiction (which I’ve been reading a lot for more than 45 years, mostly hard SF) and (to the best of my knowledge) science fiction has never explained what “Higher Dimensional Spacetime” might be, even if making reference to it, any more than has legitimate science. If I’m wrong about this, I would very much like to learn so.
Steve
You’re absolutely correct, Steve. There is zero evidence to support any hypothesis of “Higher Dimensional Spacetime.” There are some upcoming experiments at the LHC that could provide evidence to support such hypotheses, but until such results come–which is certainly not guaranteed–“higher dimensional spacetime” is the stuff of science fiction and the source of great pain for string theory supporters.
As for the Alcubierre Drive, Alcubierre didn’t think very highly at all of the possibility of a practical use of his “drive”, especially given the energy requirements and the “exotic matter” needed.
I believe that the reference to “higher dimensional spacetime” means a spacetime with a larger number of dimensions. The spacetime we’re used to interacting with is a 4-dimensional spacetime. So by “higher dimensional spacetime” they mean 5-dimensional or 8-dimensional or 37-dimensional — any spacetime with more than 4 dimensions.
Investigating the possibilities of higher dimensional spacetime is actually a very reasonable activity for research into physics. One possibility is that our 4-dimensional universe is a brane in a higher-dimensional spacetime, like the surface of a bubble is a 2-d brane in 3-d space. Another commonly considered possibility is that there are additional dimensions that wrap around after a very, very short distance, and this is why we don’t notice them, but most formulations of string theory say strings vibrating in those additional dimensions would explain certain observed properties of our universe.
Guys,
I’m famiiiar with these theories (although I’m not at all satisfied that M theory reconciles the multiple string theories), but the point I was trying to make above is that the current proposals for “warp” or FTL (that I’m aware of) don’t involve any higher/extra dimensions. Only in science fiction explanations does that show up as many writers have copied Azimov’s “hyperspace” definition (definition as opposed to explanation). Azimov claimed that there was no theory behind his hyperspace; it was just a made-up story mechanism.
There are current FTL theories, including the Alcubierre (but his we’ve rejected, as has Alcubierre himself), which require more than one spacetime, but they are just normal spacetimes, same as ours, however dimensions it may turn out to have. This situation is real. Inside and outside of the event horizon of a charged, spinning black hole are two different spacetimes, but each can be “referenced” relative to the other, and objects in one can move FTL relative to an observer in the other. The acceptable part of Alcubierre’s theory was the bubble. He creates a second spacetime without the need for a black hole. The problem lies, of course, in actually generating that second spacetime. Then there’s the need to “move” the bubble “through” our spacetime, which again is not contrary to theoretical possibilities, but figuring out how to do it remains an outstanding problem.
As far as FTL involving two spacetimes being a legitimate theory, I certainly can’t make a determination, but generally speaking, since Stephen Hawking advocates it, I’ll go along for the ride.
Steve
Just curious…Why do you say Dr. Harold White is not a
real physicist, when he holds a PhD in Physics from Rice University?
Lol there’s a very high chance it will work, we just don’t know how to induce it.
No, You haven’t done any math to show that. White’s published peer-reviewed papers which demonstrate the possibility and an actual test for the effect.
The answers from JSC don’t answer one of Keith’s questions: “Who made the funding decision(s)?” They just talk vaguely about all projects being put through “the competitive process”. I, for one, would be interested to know who exactly made the funding decision, just as Keith asked.
It sounds like this was funded from the center’s discretionary fund. This happens for projects that wouldn’t get funded otherwise. Woodward and March claimed in 2006 a force was produced with his pzt stack and the 2 MHz iron powder ring with caps in it. Sonny White has been involved in this since 2009, according to this paper on the cold fusion now web page.
http://coldfusionnow.org/wp…
Doesn’t this have a familiar ring?